A Comparison of Interventions to Teach Melanoma Patients Skin Self-examination

Northwestern University

Status: Completed

Conditions: Melanoma

Treatments: Behavioral: Workbook; Behavioral: In-person counseling; Behavioral: Tablet Computer-Based Education

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT01432860

STU17005

Details and patient eligibility

About

The almost 724,000 Americans survivors of melanoma are estimated to have 4 first degree relatives per case; thus, 2.8 million Americans are at increased risk of developing melanoma in comparison to the general public. Skin self-examination (SSE) with the assistance of a partner by these individuals could improve survival. If effective, the workbook tested in this proposal could be distributed to people at risk of developing melanoma by large scale means in physicians office.

Full description

Population based registries document that survival from melanoma, a growing public health problem with approximately 70,000 new melanoma cases and an estimated 8,600 deaths in 2010, is dependent on the thickness of the melanoma. By facilitating seeking medical care, skin self-examinations (SSEs) by individuals with a prior history of melanoma, who are at risk to develop subsequent melanomas, may lead to the early detection and treatment of melanoma when it is usually more effective. Thus, further research that enhances early detection is warranted and our application directly tests novel methods of training high-risk melanoma patients and their partners on how to conduct SSEs to promote early detection. Our proposed research builds upon the strengths of the R21 that: a) established that in-person training to conduct SSE with a partner significantly enhanced SSE performance 4 months after the intervention, and b) developed and pilot tested a manualized take-home workbook training approach (WORKBOOK). Our pilot work on the WORKBOOK with partners suggests that patient-partner dyads (n = 21) perceived it to be readable, useful, and in the short term 4 month follow-up, empirically equivalent in promoting SSE knowledge, skills, and behaviors compared with patient-partner dyads in the in-person partner training condition (n = 19). Our proposed research builds on our NCI funded studies by conducting a formal examination with 430 pairs (860 subjects) randomized to either the in-person or workbook training vs. an assessment only control group that receives standard of care over a 2 year longitudinal study with 4 month interval evaluations. An additional group of 70 pairs (140 subjects) has been added to test a tablet computer-based program.

Our proposed research directly tests novel methods of training Stage I and IIB melanoma patients, who have a 5 year survival of 80-90%, and their partners, on how to conduct SSEs. We will compare the efficacy of the in-person training vs. workbook for patients and partners vs. controls on SSE knowledge/skill acquisition and retention, and SSE performance and accuracy on a short (4 and 8 months post baseline) and long term basis (12, 16, 20, and 24 months post baseline) and examine whether partner-patient relationship-qualities moderate the relationship between the training approaches and SSEs knowledge/skill acquisition and retention, and SSE performance and accuracy. The tablet computer-based program will also be tested for efficacy and compared with the previous groups.

Establishing health promotion partnerships is important to those at risk to develop melanoma because SSE is difficult to successfully perform as an individual. It is expected that the workbook will promote SSE at least as well as and perhaps better than in-person training and become an easily disseminated SSE training approach that is not dependent on the time and teaching skills of the non-MD clinical office staff.

Enrollment: 1,000 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18 to 80 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Personal history of Stage 0 through IIB melanoma
2. At least 6 weeks post surgical treatment of Stage 0 through IIA melanoma
3. Age 18-80 years old
4. Have sufficient vision to read a newspaper in order to visually detect changes on skin
5. Able to read English
6. Have a partner willing to participate in skin checks

Exclusion criteria

1.Subjects overburdened with other co- morbid diseases, medical treatments (e.g. chemotherapy), unable to participate in a conversation at a sixth grade language level due to cognitive impairment (e.g. by a stroke), or prior participation in SSE research.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Screening

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

1,000 participants in 4 patient groups

In-person Counseling and Education

Active Comparator group

Description:

In the in-person training the Research Assistant demonstrates the use of a mm ruler, a lighted magnifying lens, a set of body maps and a scorecard, 4 pens, ABCDE rule on the skin exam card and discusses the ABCDE rule by pointing to the color examples on the skin exam card. 165 pairs (330 subjects) are randomized to this arm.

Treatment:

Behavioral: In-person counseling

Workbook

Active Comparator group

Description:

The workbook, which includes all of the information delivered in the in-person intervention, is 39 pages in length, and has 76 color figures. Each element of the in-person training represents a chapter in the workbook. The introduction explores the partners' understanding of melanoma and their personal risk of developing another melanoma, and attitudes about the benefit of early detection assisted by a partner. The early detection segment uses a skin diagram to illustrate the difference between thin and thick melanoma and presents the treatment based on the depth of the melanoma. 165 pairs (330 subjects) are randomized to this arm.

Treatment:

Behavioral: Workbook

Control

No Intervention group

Description:

Education and counseling as usually delivered in clinical practice. 100 pairs (200 subjects) are randomized to this arm.

Tablet Computer-Based Education

Active Comparator group

Description:

Education will be given by an interactive tablet app. Each pair will view video recordings of certain parts of the in-person presentation as well as select slides from the in-person PowerPoint presentation. Parts of the workbook will be incorporated as well. 70 pairs (140 subjects) are randomized into this arm.

Treatment:

Behavioral: Tablet Computer-Based Education