A Randomized, Real-world Head-to-head Study of Dupilumab Versus Mepolizumab in Danish CRSwNP Patients (TORNADO)
Status and phase
Conditions
Treatments
Details and patient eligibility
About
The goal of this randomized clinical trial is to compare the effects of two newly available biological drugs for the treatment of severe chronic rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps in Danish patients.
The main questions it aims to answer are whether the two drugs are comparable in effect after 24 weeks in terms of:
- A subjective score (the SNOT-22)
- An objective score, i.e.the physician-assessed score of nasal polyp size (the Nasal Polyp Score (0-8))
Methods:
Participants will be randomized to receive one of the IMPs drug in the standard dose. After 24 weeks the effect is assessed by subjective and objective measures. If the criteria set by the Danish Medicinal Council are met (see elsewhere), treatment continues with the same drug for an additional 24 weeks. If the effect criteria are not met, the subject crosses-over to the opposite drug for an additional 24 weeks. After 48 weeks the effect is assessed once more.
Full description
Objectives:
-
The primary objective is to
- establish non-inferiority of dupilumab versus mepolizumab, and if that is established, then
- test for possible superiority of dupilumab over mepolizumab in the following hierarchical order (SNOT-22 - Sniffin' Sticks 16 - NPS - ACQ
-
The secondary objective is to explore any other relevant differences between mepolizumab and dupilumab in terms of frequency of AEs, need for rescue treatments, diversity in outcome based on endotype or comorbidity or other factors, that can lead to a patient-centred approach, when choosing treatment for CRSwNP.
Trial design:
A randomized, multi-center non-inferiority trial (phase IV RCT). The trial is unblinded.
Investigational medicinal products (IMPs) will be "off-the-shelf" and administered in EMA-approved dosages and -intervals.
Trial population:
The trial aims to include 220 patients with severe, uncontrolled CRSwNP (110 patients in each treatment group). The patients will be recruited from 9 different sites across Denmark. Treatment in Denmark is 100% subsidized by the state.
Methods:
Subjects fulfilling inclusion criteria will be randomized 1:1 to either dupilumab or mepolizumab. After 24 weeks a halfway evaluation will decide if subjects are to stay in their current treatment arm, or cross-over to the opposite arm.
By including 220 participants (effectively 176 participants after 20% drop-outs) the study will achieve a power of >95% to show non-inferiority of dupilumab to mepolizumab for both co-primary endpoints with the following criteria: Level of significance for both endpoints of a one-sided test, p<0.025 and including previously found standard deviation (SD) values 1.9 for NPS and 22 for SNOT-22, an expected superior effect of 0.7 for NPS and 7 on SNOT-22, a minimal clinically relevant difference (MCID) of 1 for NPS and 12 for SNOT-22, respectively.
Trial medication:
All trial medication will be "off the shelf" i.e. no special labelling. It will be provided by hospital pharmacies in accordance with GMP. The investigational medicinal products (IMPs) are dupilumab (Dupixent, Sanofi) and mepolizumab (Nucala, GSK). Dupilumab are administered as subcutaneous injections of 300 mg every two weeks in the first 24 weeks. If the DMC response criteria (table 2) are met after 24 weeks, the dosing interval will be increased to every four weeks, in accordance with previous research and DMC recommendations. Mepolizumab is administered subcutaneously as 100 mg sc. every four weeks. Patients will continue standard of care treatment of INCS and saline irrigation, unless contraindicated.
If rescue treatment is needed, a course of oral corticosteroids (Prednisolone) 37.5 mg once daily for 7 days will be given.
Trial schedule:
Planned first subject first visit May 2023
Planned last subject randomized February 2025
Planned last subject last visit:March 2026
End of trial March 2026
Enrollment
Sex
Ages
Volunteers
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Inclusion Criteria:
- Bilateral polyps in nose and sinuses
- ESS within the last three years (unless unfit for surgery y- in this study defined as either a severe somatic disease, for which other specialist advise against surgery, e.g., cardiac disease, pulmonary disease, or coagulation disorder OR/AND severe anxiety which can either be due to previous traumatic experiences with surgery or the postoperative period, post-traumatic stress disorder or severe anxiety disorder. In cases of doubt, investigators can ask for a written statement from the general practitioner or a psychiatrists/psychologist))
- Optimal local treatment with saline irrigation and topical nasal steroids for at least three months (unless contraindicated)
- Evidence of type 2 inflammation
Furthermore, patients must fulfil three out the following five criteria:
- Need for systemic corticosteroids (at least two courses/year OR long-term treatment >3 months) or contraindication to systemic steroids
- Significantly impaired QoL (SNOT-22 score≥50)
- Significant LoS (SSIT-16 score 0-8)
- NPS ≥5 (with at least 2 on either side)
- Asthma diagnosis (requiring inhaled corticosteroid (ICS))
Also: Age of 18 years or more and able to read and/or speak Danish
Exclusion criteria
- Systemic corticosteroid treatment within the last three months
- Endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS) within the last six months
- Non-adherent to medicine regimens
- Hypersensitivity to the active substance or any of the excipients in the two IMPs
- Not able to understand spoken and/or written Danish
- Participation-current or previous (within the last year)-in another investigational drug trial with monoclonal antibodies for asthma, CRSwNP, atopic dermatitis or allergic rhinitis.
- Previous treatment failure with one of the IMPs for any indication (treatment failure is defined as failure to achieve the desired therapeutic outcome or effectively manage a condition within an expected timeframe)
- Eosinophilic blood cell count of ≥1.5x10^9cells/L (at baseline, i.e. before first injection)
- Pronounced fear of needles
- Pregnant or breastfeeding patients
Trial design
Primary purpose
Allocation
Interventional model
Masking
220 participants in 5 patient groups
Trial contacts and locations
Loading...
Central trial contact
Christian Pedersen, MD
Data sourced from clinicaltrials.gov
Clinical trials
Research sites
Resources
Legal