Accelerating Word Learning in Children With Language Impairment

Kansas Board of Regents

Status: Completed

Conditions: Specific Language Impairment

Treatments: Behavioral: Treatment (interactive book reading, dialogic reading, shared book reading)

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other; NIH

Identifiers

NCT01829360

R01DC012824 (U.S. NIH Grant/Contract)

Details and patient eligibility

About

This research attempts to adapt and optimize a word learning treatment, specifically interactive book reading, for use with Kindergarten children with Specific Language Impairment (SLI). Children with SLI have difficulty learning language without any obvious cause for this difficulty. This study will examine the best way to achieve the appropriate intensity of 36 exposures. For example, is it better to hear the new words many times within the book (high dose) and to read the book few times (low dose frequency), or is it better to hear the new words a few times within the book (low dose) and to read the book many times (high dose frequency). The investigators hypothesize that reading the books many times will be more effective than repeating the words many times within a book.

Full description

Specific Language Impairment (SLI) affects approximately 7.4% of Kindergarten children. Children with SLI are known to have difficulty learning new words, which places them at greater risk for future reading impairments and academic failure. Surprisingly, there are few interventions for word learning by children with SLI that have undergone rigorous efficacy and/or effectiveness testing. The goal of this research is to optimize an interactive book reading intervention that has proven to be successful in teaching vocabulary to other groups of Kindergarten children. A secondary goal was to examine whether pre-treatment characteristics predicted how many words children would learn.

This study further tests the adequate intensity of 36 exposures. Each child will receive two treatments at the identified adequate intensity. Children were randomized to two treatments: the standard treatment and 1 of 2 alternative treatments. The standard treatment used in prior research was balanced between the amount of times the new word is heard within the book (dose 6) and the amount of times the book is read (dose frequency 6). The alternative treatments were more heavily weighted for either repetitions within the book (high dose/low dose frequency, i.e., dose 9 x dose frequency 4) or the amount of times the book is read (low dose/high dose frequency, i.e., dose 4 x dose frequency 9). Ultimately, this study determines how best to achieve the adequate intensity of 36 exposures.

A secondary goal was to further examine the pre-treatment factors associated with the number of words learned by children with SLI during interactive book reading. We once again explore a variety of potential predictors including those that were significant in a prior study (i.e., phonological awareness, nonword repetition, and semantics) as well as those that were not significant in a prior study but that had the potential to be related to a child's ability to learn during interactive book reading. That is, a child's general language abilities (as measured by the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-4, CELF-4, Core Language score) and their ability to understand verbally presented stories (as measured by the CELF-4 Understanding Spoken Paragraphs score) could impact their success in encoding new words during interactive book reading.

Enrollment: 35 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 5 to 6 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Eligible for Kindergarten enrollment
• Age 5 to 6 years
• Normal hearing
• Nonverbal Intelligence Quotient (IQ) of 85 or higher on the Reynolds Intellectual Assessment Scale
• Score below 82 on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals
• Score at or below the 10% percentile on one of the approved standardized vocabulary assessments.

Exclusion criteria

• Speaks more than one language
• Health history indicating neurologic or other disorder that would exclude a diagnosis of SLI (e.g., autism, developmental disability, seizure disorder)

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Crossover Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

35 participants in 4 patient groups

Standard then Alternative: High Dose

Experimental group

Description:

Children in this arm are assigned to the standard treatment for the first round of intervention (dose 6 x dose frequency 6) and then the alternative treatment that maximizes dose (dose 9 x dose frequency 4)

Treatment:

Behavioral: Treatment (interactive book reading, dialogic reading, shared book reading)

Alternative: High Dose then Standard

Experimental group

Description:

Children in this arm are assigned to the alternative treatment that maximizes dose (dose 9 x dose frequency 4) in the first round of intervention and then to the standard treatment for the second round of intervention (dose 6 x dose frequency 6)

Treatment:

Behavioral: Treatment (interactive book reading, dialogic reading, shared book reading)

Alternative: High Dose Frequency then Standard

Experimental group

Description:

Children in this arm are assigned to the alternative treatment that maximizes dose frequency (dose 4 x dose frequency 9) in the first round of intervention and then to the standard treatment for the second round of intervention (dose 6 x dose frequency 6)

Treatment:

Behavioral: Treatment (interactive book reading, dialogic reading, shared book reading)

Standard then Alternative: High Dose Frequency

Experimental group

Description:

Children in this arm are assigned to the standard treatment for the first round of intervention (dose 6 x dose frequency 6) and then the alternative treatment that maximizes dose frequency (dose 4 x dose frequency 9)

Treatment:

Behavioral: Treatment (interactive book reading, dialogic reading, shared book reading)