BLB Study Back or Leg Pain and Bladder Symptoms Study

University of Edinburgh

Status: Completed

Conditions: Cauda Equina Syndrome; Functional Neurological Disorder

Treatments: Other: Questionnaires and examination

Study type: Observational

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT03325374

15/NS/0112

Details and patient eligibility

About

The research focuses on Cauda Equina Syndrome (CES) which describes damage to the nerves in the lower back which supply bladder, bowels, sexual function and the legs usually from slipped discs in the spine.

CES is as common as multiple sclerosis and is diagnosed using an MRI scan of the spine, 'scan positive' CES. However, about 50% of people presenting with the symptoms of CES have MRI scans which do not explain their symptoms, 'scan negative' patients. The BLB study will be the first large clinical study comparing patients with 'scan positive' and 'scan negative' CES. All patients admitted to the Western General Hospital, Edinburgh with possible CES will be invited to participate. The study consists of detailed history taking, examination and a questionnaire following up patient's symptoms at three months.

The study aims to see what differences exist between the 'scan positive' and 'scan negative' groups, help doctors understand more about the outcomes of both groups and discover the number of patients with 'scan negative' CES who have functional disorders (previously called medically unexplained or conversion disorders) or undiagnosed neurological disorders.

Full description

Uro-neurological disorders are those in which there is a disturbance of bladder function related to a neurological cause. However, many patients with Uro-Neurological disorders are not found to have explanatory abnormalities despite adequate clinical and radiological investigation, so-called 'scan negative' patients. The BLB study will investigate this problem through an acute disorder, Cauda Equina Syndrome (CES), to provide a better understanding of scan-negative Uro-Neurological disorders.

CES is a devastating condition caused by compression of the cauda equina nerve roots resulting in bowel, bladder and sexual dysfunction with potential lower limb weakness. CES requires urgent surgery and has serious potential morbidity and medico-legal consequences1. Suspected acute CES has a minimum incidence of 11 per 100,000 making it twice as common as multiple sclerosis. However, in the two largest studies both retrospective and from Edinburgh, 43-48% of patients with clinical CES were 'scan-negative' and indeed received no other diagnosis 1,2.

Little is known about patients with 'scan negative' CES and nothing is known about their outcome. Our two studies in Edinburgh found basic clinical and demographic characteristics could not distinguish 'scan positive' and 'scan negative' groups 1,2. However, on the basis of clinical experience, and now prospective pilot data, the investigators hypothesise that many of these patients have either an acute functional disorder or, in some cases, sacral nerve damage not seen on imaging but detectable on anal sphincter EMG. Functional disorders, also called psychogenic/non-organic disorders, refer to genuinely experienced physical symptoms which can be positively identified as not related to underlying neurological disease3. Finding out about the diagnosis of patients with 'scan negative' CES would enable them to access treatment and improve their outcome as well as creating better service provision for them in the long term. There is also limited data on long term outcome in patients with 'scan positive' CES and a wish for knowledge from the medical community about what the priorities for patients with 'scan positive' CES are after discharge. The investigators have called the study subsection 'Back or Leg pain with Bladder symptoms' (BLB) study because this most accurately describes the symptoms patients have and we know that describing something negatively to patients (e.g. medically unexplained symptoms)is found by patients to be unhelpful.

The BLB study asks three main questions; do patients with 'scan negative' CES have symptoms of bowel, bladder, sexual dysfunction and lower limb weakness and sensory abnormalities due to a functional disorder?; do a proportion of patients with 'scan negative' CES have missed neurological disease?; what are the outcomes of patients with 'scan negative' and 'scan positive' CES after three months?

Enrollment: 100 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 16 to 100 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Ability to give informed consent
2. Able to complete online or paper questionnaire.
3. Patients admitted to the regional neurosurgical unit, Western General Hospital, Edinburgh with suspected cauda equina syndrome for an MRI scan. Demographic data from all patients attending any NHS Lothian site who have an MRI scan for suspected CES.

Exclusion criteria

1. Age less than 16
2. Inability to communicate (e.g. do not speak English)
3. Inability to complete written or oral surveys or give informed consent
4. Age over 100. The upper age limit is set at 100 to allow the greatest number of participants the opportunity to take part. As the study is a follow up study concerns about mortality and high drop out in this age group led to the upper limit of 100 being set.

Trial design

100 participants in 1 patient group

BLB patients

Description:

Patients admitted for urgent MRI with possible cauda equina syndrome will be consented for questionnaires and examination.

Treatment:

Other: Questionnaires and examination