Brain Metastases in Greater Size - Hypofractionated Options Trial (BIGSHOT)

Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC)

Status and phase: Enrolling; Phase 2

Conditions: Brain Metastases; Cancer (With CNS Involvement)

Treatments: Radiation: Fractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy (FSRT); Radiation: Staged Stereotactic Radiosurgery (SSRS)

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT07227610

104122

Details and patient eligibility

About

This is a randomized, phase II trial comparing staged stereotactic radiosurgery (SSRS) versus fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT) in patients with large brain metastases (≥2 cm and ≤5 cm). The study aims to evaluate efficacy, safety, and tumor response between these two standard-of-care radiation approaches.

Full description

Brain metastases are an increasingly common diagnosis, as cancer patients continue to live longer due to advances in systemic therapy. Up to 26% of patients with metastatic cancer will develop metastatic disease to the brain (Nayak 2012), most commonly in lung cancer, as well as melanoma, breast, and renal cell cancer (Singh 2020). Historically, brain metastases were treated with whole brain radiation therapy (WBRT). However, increasing evidence over the past 10-15 years, as well as technological advances, have created a shift in treatment toward stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), which is a focused treatment targeting only the visible tumors. SRS has multiple advantages over WBRT. Most importantly, focused treatment with SRS provides significantly lower risk of neurocognitive toxicity compared with WBRT, with no difference in overall survival (Chang 2009, Brown 2016, Aoyama 2006). SRS is also more convenient, delivered in 1 to 3 treatments, as opposed to 2 weeks of therapy with WBRT. For these reasons, SRS is now the preferred option for patients with limited brain metastases, recognized in both the NCCN guidelines and ASTRO guidelines (Gondi 2022).

For intact metastases less than 2 cm, local control with SRS alone is excellent (Redmond 2021). However, for larger tumors, achieving long term local control with radiation is more difficult. Tumor dosing is based on risk of toxicity (specifically, radiation necrosis), and therefore for larger tumors, the dose is decreased (RTOG 90-05, Johannwerner 2023). This results in suboptimal control for tumors >2 cm. For single fraction SRS, local control is estimated around 70%, and for fractionated SRS (3-5 fractions), around 80% (Redmond 2021).

There are two common approaches for treating large intact brain metastases with radiosurgery alone. Fractionated SRS involves treating the tumor in 3-5 separate daily treatments. This allows for normal tissue recovery in between, and therefore may decrease the risk of toxicity (Minitti 2015). Staged SRS involves treating the tumor in two sessions, spaced apart by 3-6 weeks. This allows delivery of a lower dose for the first fraction (to minimize toxicity), and the second fraction can be dose escalated depending on interval tumor response. A recent meta-analysis compared SSRS to FSRT, and found no difference in local control, but a lower rate of re-treatment in the SSRS group (Harikar 2023). Radiation necrosis rate was 3.7% in the SSRS group and 6.4% in the FSRT group. The authors of this study concluded that randomized controlled trials examining the two options would be useful. A retrospective study conducted a propensity score-matched analysis of SSRS vs FSRT. This study showed comparable rates of local failure (15% at 6 months, and 25% at one year in both groups), as well as comparable rates of radiation necrosis (2.2% in SSRS vs 6.4% in FSRT) (Noda 2023).

In theory, treatment with SSRS would allow for a higher biological equivalent dose (BED) to the target lesion, while maintaining low toxicity rate, as time between fractions allows for normal tissue recovery. Retrospective data suggests that a BED10 > 50 predicts for better one year local control in hypofractionated SRS (Remick 2020). BED10 for 9 Gy x3 is 51.3Gy, with an EQD2 a/b 2 of 74.25. In comparison, 15 Gy x2 results in a BED10 of 75Gy, with EQD2 a/b 2 of 127.5. Allowing 3-6 weeks of recovery time in between the two fractions should theoretically allow for tissue recovery and mitigate the risk of higher normal tissue EQD2. Additionally, while data for 3 fraction FSRT is encouraging for larger tumors (2-5 cm), the local control for tumors on the larger end of this spectrum (>3 cm) may not be as good. Specifically, in one of the largest retrospective studies of 3 fraction FSRT for metastases >2cm, the overall local control was 91% at 1 year; however, the local control for lesions 3 cm or larger was only 73% (Minniti 2015).

Although there is encouraging retrospective data supporting the use of both SSRS and FSRT, there are no studies directly comparing the two approaches in a prospective fashion. Therefore, randomized data is needed to provide guidance on the best approach in this challenging patient population.

This study will compare two approaches for treating large brain metastases (2-5 cm): staged stereotactic radiosurgery (SSRS) and fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy (FSRT). These are both considered standard treatments and both used as standard of care for patients with large brain metastases.

Enrollment: 54 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. The patient or a legally authorized representative must be able and willing to provide study-specific informed consent prior to study entry.

2. Patient must be willing to comply with all study procedures and available for the duration of the study

3. Male or female, aged ≥ 18 years

4. Karnofsky Performance Status (KPS) ≥ 60 within 7 days prior to registration

5. Radiographic confirmation of brain metastasis measuring ≥2 cm and ≤ 5 cm in maximum diameter

   1. Multiple metastases are allowed. Additional metastases will be treated with single fraction SRS as per standard of care. Up to 10 additional smaller metastases are allowed on protocol. All additional smaller metastases must be less than 2 cm.
   2. If a patient has more than one large metastasis (measuring between 2 and 5 cm as above), up to two can be treated on study protocol
   3. All tumors must be ≥ 5mm from the optic chiasm and optic nerves.

6. Known active or history of invasive non-CNS primary cancer based on documented pathologic diagnosis within the past 3 years

7. Patient is able to medically tolerate SRS

8. Patient is neurologically stable (immediate surgery not necessary or not recommended)

9. A negative urine or serum pregnancy test (in persons of childbearing potential) within 7 days prior to registration. Childbearing potential is defined as any person who has experienced menarche and who has not undergone surgical sterilization (hysterectomy or bilateral oophorectomy) or who is not postmenopausal.

10. Participants who are sexually active must agree to use medically acceptable forms of contraception during treatment on this study to prevent pregnancy.

Exclusion criteria

1. Prior cranial radiotherapy, including whole brain radiotherapy (WBRT), or SRS in the area of the large metastasis to be treated on study.
2. Evidence of leptomeningeal disease (LMD) Note: For the purposes of exclusion, LMD is a clinical diagnosis, defined as positive CSF cytology and/or unequivocal radiologic or clinical evidence of leptomeningeal involvement. Patients with leptomeningeal symptoms in the setting of leptomeningeal enhancement by imaging (MRI) would be considered to have LMD even in the absence of positive CSF cytology. In contrast, an asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic patient with mild or nonspecific leptomeningeal enhancement (MRI) would not be considered to have LMD. In such cases, CSF sampling is not required to formally exclude LMD, but can be performed at the investigator's discretion based on level of clinical suspicion.
3. Inability to undergo MRI with contrast
4. Planned administration of systemic therapy (chemotherapy or immunotherapy) within 3 days prior to, the day of, or 3 days after completion of SRS.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

54 participants in 2 patient groups

Staged Stereotactic Radiosurgery (SSRS)

Experimental group

Description:

Patient will be scheduled for treatment with SSRS within one week of randomization. The large brain metastasis (or metastases) will be treated to a dose of 24-30 Gy in two fractions. Interval between the two fractions will be 30 days (+/- 10 days). MRI brain for planning purposes will be obtained either on the day of each treatment, or within 7 days prior to each treatment. Individual dosing for each fraction will be determined by the treating radiation oncologist, but total dose must equal 24-30 Gy. Any additional smaller metastases will be treated in a single fraction concurrently. Fixation for treatment will be either in a surgical headframe or mask.

Treatment:

Radiation: Staged Stereotactic Radiosurgery (SSRS)

Fractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy (FSRT)

Experimental group

Description:

Patient will be scheduled for treatment with FSRT within one week of randomization. FSRT will be performed with mask fixation. Fractionation will be 27 Gy in 3 daily fractions. The 3 daily fractions must be completed over a period of 3-5 days. MRI for planning purposes must be completed within 7 days prior to delivery of first fraction. Any additional smaller metastases will be treated in a single fraction concurrently.

Treatment:

Radiation: Fractionated Stereotactic Radiotherapy (FSRT)