Bryophyllum Pinnatum Versus Solifenacin Versus Placebo for Overactive Bladder (BryoSoliP)

University of Zurich (UZH)

Status and phase: Terminated; Phase 3; Phase 2

Conditions: Urge Urinary Incontinence; Overactive Bladder

Treatments: Drug: Bryophyllum

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02129816

KEK 2012-0530 (Zurich) (Registry Identifier)

BryoSoliP-2014

Details and patient eligibility

About

Overactive bladder (OAB) is an enigmatic condition that is treated symptomatically with anticholinergic drugs (gold standard 2013). In a clinical pilot study was found to be a trend for a higher reduction of the micturition frequency in the Bryophyllum pinnatum group - treated with chewing tablets containing 50% of dried BP leaf press juice - than in the placebo group (n=20, p=0.064) Hypothesis: To test the superior effectivity of Bryophyllum versus Placebo in the treatment of OAB with the needed number (Purpose 1) and to assess in an experimental arm the side effects of BP in comparison to the standard drug (Vesicare) in a clincial trial (Purpose 2).

Full description

• In a US nation-wide survey, lower urinary tract symptoms are one of the strongest predictors that patients will seek complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) care. In comparison to general gynecological patients, urogynecological patients are particularly prone to seek help in CAM. Moreover out of the different CAM options, herbal medication is one of the most preferred treatments. However, the effectiveness of CAM regarding OAB has not yet been adequately and objectively evaluated. Therefore, it is timely and essential to elucidate the mode of action as well as to prove efficacy of herbal treatments by a translational approach including comprehensive in vitro experimentation and randomized controlled clinical trials. Bryophyllum pinnatum and specially the flavonoid components have shown a muscle relaxing effect on porcine bladder strips.
• Study Design: Multicenter, prospective, double-blind randomized, placebo-controlled cross-over study, phase III to test the superiority of Bryophyllum pinnatum (BP) over placebo in the treatment of overactive bladder.
• In this cross-over trial a total of 30 patients is needed to proof the superiority of BP over placebo (5 randomization blocs, each 6 patients). Each patient gets each of the three study drugs (BP, Solifenacin, Placebo) in a double-blind randomization. The number of patients was calculated in a post-hoc analysis based on the primary endpoint of a previous study (reduction of micturition rates/24hours; 9.5 (SD2.2) before and 7.8 (SD1.2) after Bryophyllum versus 9.3 (SD1.8) before and 9.1(SD1.6) after placebo), under the assumption of a normal data distribution and a power of 80% a patient number of 2x20. Plus 10% for non-parametric tests in the case of a non-normal distribution (Wilcoxon) were added, what generated a number of 2x22 patients.
• In order to facilitate an equality in the randomization, the investigator choose a cross-over design. Due to the length of the study time, the drop-out rate was risen from 10 to 20% what yielded under the assumption of a equal block randomization the number of 30 patients. Additionally, an explorative arm containing the standard medication Vesicare was inserted, as this is of great clinical interest. For this explorative comparative arm are no existing data that would allow to do a power calculation.
• This follow-up study will give a compelling answer on the efficacy or non-efficacy of BP as well as the safety of BP in respect to placebo and possible answers of its position regarding the standard medication Vesicare.

Enrollment: 9 patients

Sex: Female

Ages: 40+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• OAB (>8 micturitions/24 hours, associated with urge symptoms)
• postmenopausal women
• cystoscopy to exclude a bladder carcinoma or carcinoma in situ
• written and oral informed consent

Exclusion criteria

• urinary tract infection in an intermittent catheter asservated sample (>1000 bacterias/ml)
• intake of bladder affecting drugs like anticholinergics, diuretics, muscle relaxing medications and phytotherapeutics in the last three months
• neurological conditions such as stroke, multiple sclerosis, spinal cord injury or Parkinsons's disease
• postvoid residual volume ≥100 ml
• lactose intolerance
• contraindication for Solifenacin

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Crossover Assignment

Masking: Quadruple Blind

---

9 participants in 3 patient groups, including a placebo group

Bryophyllum

Active Comparator group

Description:

50% in 350mg Lactose, 2-2-2

Treatment:

Drug: Bryophyllum

Placebo

Placebo Comparator group

Description:

Lactose 350mg, 2-2-2

Treatment:

Drug: Bryophyllum

Solifenacin

Experimental group

Description:

10mg in 350mg Lactose, 2-2-2

Treatment:

Drug: Bryophyllum