Comparison of Alcohol and Steroid Injection for Treating Morton's Neuroma

Brown University

Status

Unknown

Conditions

Morton's Neuroma

Treatments

Drug: Injection of Lidocaine into Foot

Drug: Injection of Steroid into Foot

Drug: Injection of Alcohol into Foot

Study type

Interventional

Funder types

Other

Identifiers

NCT00284583

0061-05

Details and patient eligibility

About

Interdigital neuroma is a painful forefoot disorder characterized by plantar pain and toe paresthesias thought to result from entrapment of the interdigital nerve by the overlying transverse metatarsal ligament. Multiple treatments have been recommended for this condition and range from modification of shoe wear to surgical excision of the painful nerve. Serial ethanol injection therapy has been reported to be an effective alternative to surgical excision. However, despite wide adoption of this treatment, no randomized, double blinded, placebo-controlled study exists to verify the efficacy of this treatment in comparison to longer standing similar therapies, such as corticosteroid injection.

120 patients from one Orthopaedic group's foot and ankle offices with single foot neuromas and no previous history of neuroma or foot disorder treatment will be selected for the study. These patients will be randomized to three treatments, specifically lidocaine injection, corticosteroid injection, or ethanol injection. Outcomes will be assessed at 3, 6 and 12 month time points using validated questionnaires as well as a non-validated disease specific questionnaire. Primary endpoint will be graded change in the physical function portion of the SF-36 form. Secondary endpoints will be the graded change in the McGill Short Form for Pain and ultimate satisfaction with treatment as assessed by a non-validated questionnaire designed for Morton's neuroma symptoms.

Full description

Interdigital neuroma, or Morton's Neuroma, is a painful forefoot disorder characterized by plantar pain and paresthesias radiating to toes. The condition was first described in 1845 by Lewis Durlacher as a painful "neuralgic affection" of the plantar nerve between the third and fourth metatarsals. T.G. Morton, in 1876, attributed the painful symptom complex to a "neuroma." His observation was confirmed by Hoadley who, in 1893, performed a curative excision of a "neuroma" between the third and fourth metatarsals.

Current understanding of interdigital neuroma is based on Gauthier's conclusion in 1979 that the symptom complex was a result of an entrapment neuropathy of the interdigital nerve by the overlying transverse metatarsal ligament. Presently, no definitive single etiology has been confirmed. Additional potential pathoetiologies include the aberrant anatomy of the plantar nerve in this location, trauma and extrinsic mass effect above or below the level of the transverse metatarsal ligament.(3,6) The histological appearance of the affected nerve, however, is consistent and suggests that "neuroma" is a misnomer for this condition. The nerve tissue demonstrates demyelination and deposition of amorphous eosinophilic material, but no exuberant proliferation of nerve endings characteristic of neuroma.(3)

Multiple treatments have been recommended for the management of interdigital neuroma. The usual algorithm begins with an attempt at conservative therapy consisting of shoe wear modifications and the application of a metatarsal pad. Failure of conservative management may prompt a trial of corticosteroid injections.(8) Persistent symptoms ultimately require surgical excision or division of the transverse metatarsal ligament, both of which have good long term outcomes in literature.(2,7)

Recently, serial ethanol injection therapy has been reported to be an effective alternative to surgical excision and has been widely adopted in the treatment of Morton's neuroma. Dockery et. al. reported 89% success rate in a series of 100 consecutive patients treated with 3 to 7 injections of 4% ethanol solutions with an average follow-up of 13 months. Fanucci and Masala reported a 90% success rate at 10 month follow-up after 3 to 7 injections of 30% alcohol in a consecutive series of 40 patients. However, none of these studies were performed in a randomized, double blinded fashion with adequate controls. Therefore, no scientifically valid conclusions concerning treatment efficacy can be made.

The proposed study investigates alcohol sclerosing therapy for the treatment of Morton's neuroma in a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial. The primary end point will be evaluation of patient physical function according to the standardized SF-36 questionnaire after the treatment period. Secondary end points include evaluation of pain and satisfaction levels after treatment using, respectively, a standardized and a novel questionnaire.

Sex

All

Ages

18 to 60 years old

Volunteers

Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

2 months of 2 or more of the following

Plantar pain increased by walking localized to the 2nd and 3rd interspaces
Relief of pain by resting
Pain radiating into toes
Numbness in toes or foot
Cramping in toes and foot

2 or More of the Following physical Findings
Plantar tenderness
Radiation of elicited pain into the toes
Palpable plantar mass
Numbness in toes
Exacerbation of symptoms with Mulder's maneuver

Exclusion criteria

Past treatment for Morton's neuroma or had prior foot surgery.
Concurrent conditions such as hallux valgus, metatarsalgia, lesser toe abnormalities, atraumatic synovitis of metatarsophalangeal joint and other foot and ankle based nerve compression neuropathies.
Further, patients with neuroma symptoms in the 1st and 4th interspaces.