Comparison of Nebulizers in ED in Pediatric Asthma Patients

Seton Healthcare Family

Status and phase: Terminated; Phase 4

Conditions: Asthma

Treatments: Device: Hudson RCI® nebulizer; Device: NebuTech® HDN® nebulizer; Drug: Albuterol

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT01951378

CR-13-119

Details and patient eligibility

About

The primary objective will be, in an open-label randomized trial, a comparison of emergency department (ED) length of stay (LOS) between children experiencing acute asthma treated with two different nebulizers. Secondary outcomes will include admission rates, hospital LOS, need for additional therapies, transfers to a higher level of care, side-effects, and unscheduled return visits

Full description

To our knowledge, no study has compared a breath-enhanced nebulizer to a standard jet nebulizer for the treatment of acute asthma in children. The goal of this study is to determine whether a rapid albuterol delivery pathway with a breath-enhanced nebulizer can reduce ED LOS, while maintaining admission rates, repeat visits, adjunctive therapies, and side-effects, when compared to a traditional asthma pathway with a standard jet nebulizer. The Salter® Nebutech® HDN® was chosen because its breath-enhanced design and bolus delivery system may deliver greater amounts of albuterol to the small airways, in a shorter period of time, when compared with standard jet nebulizers and other nebulizers in its class.

The study site will be a large, urban pediatric emergency department (ED) with approximately 80,000 visits per year. The study protocol will be submitted to the hospital's Institutional Review Board (IRB) for approval. Children will be eligible for enrolment if they are between 3 and 18 years of age and present to the ED with an acute asthma exacerbation of at least moderate severity. The lower age cutoff was chosen because asthma diagnosis and beta agonist response can be unreliable in younger children. The upper age cutoff was chosen to include only pediatric patients, as this is a pediatric asthma study. Children must have a history of physician-diagnosed asthma as reported by the parent or guardian. Children will be enrolled when a research team member is available to obtain informed consent (convenience sample). Children will be excluded from enrollment if the initial pediatric asthma score (PAS) is < 3, immediate resuscitation is required, they have a history of chronic lung disease or congenital heart disease, they have any neuromuscular disease, intrathoracic foreign body is suspected, they are or may be pregnant, they are currently breast feeding, they have received oral or parenteral steroids within the last week (inhaled steroids are allowed), or they have an allergy or other contraindication to one of the study medications.

Potential subjects will be identified in triage and screened for enrolment if study personnel are available. If consented, the patient will be randomized to one of the two treatment arms. If there will be greater than a 15 minute delay in treatment due to the consent process, unit dose (2.5 mg) albuterol treatments will be given with a standard nebulizer up to 3 times as needed. That patient may still be enrolled provided he/she still meets inclusion/exclusion criteria.

Enrollment: 40 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 3 to 17 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Age ≥ 3 years and < 18 years
• History of physician-diagnosed asthma
• Presenting to ED with acute asthma exacerbation according to attending physician

Exclusion criteria

• PAS score < 3
• Immediate resuscitation required
• Chronic lung disease (other than asthma)
• Congenital heart disease 5. Neuromuscular disease 6. Suspected intrathoracic foreign body 7. Is or may be pregnant 8. Currently breast feeding 9. Oral or parenteral steroids within the last 7 days 10. Allergy or other contraindication to any of the study medications

Trial design

Primary purpose: Supportive Care

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

40 participants in 2 patient groups

Hudson RCI® nebulizer

Active Comparator group

Description:

Patients randomized to the "standard" arm will receive treatments as dictated by our standard ED asthma pathway (Fig. 1). All treatments will be administered with our standard ED nebulizer, the Hudson RCI® Up-Draft® Neb-U-Mist® nebulizer (Teleflex Medical®, Research Triangle Park, NJ), and a simple mask (Hudson RCI®, Teleflex Medical®, Research Triangle Park, NJ).

Treatment:

Drug: Albuterol

Device: Hudson RCI® nebulizer

NebuTech® HDN® nebulizer

Active Comparator group

Description:

Patients randomized to the "NebuTech®" arm will receive treatments as dictated by our trial pathway, referred to as the "rapid Albuterol/Proventil delivery pathway" (Fig. 2). All nebulizations in this arm will be administered via the Breath-Enhanced High Density Jet Nebulizer, NebuTech® HighDensityNebulizer®,(Salter Labs®, Arvin, CA). Respiratory Therapists (RT) will attempt to deliver all treatments with a mouthpiece, as that has been shown to be the most efficient and reliable mode of aerosol delivery for most children 31, 32. If the Respiratory Therapist feels that the child will not or cannot effectively use a mouthpiece, a mask will be used.

Treatment:

Drug: Albuterol

Device: NebuTech® HDN® nebulizer