Comparison of Two Therapies for Upper Esophageal Sphincter (UES) Dysphagia

National Institutes of Health (NIH)

Status: Completed

Conditions: Deglutition Disorders

Treatments: Procedure: Shaker Exercise vs. Traditional Dysphagia Therapy Regime

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: NIH

Identifiers

NCT00059670

UESD (completed)

Details and patient eligibility

About

The aim of this research study is to determine the effectiveness of: 1) a traditional therapy regimen focusing on individual exercises for pharyngeal (throat) and laryngeal (voice box) musculature and 2) a new therapeutic exercise, the Shaker exercise.

The primary objective of this 5-year project is to identify which of two therapy programs, the Shaker exercise versus traditional therapy, results in the largest number of stable, non-oral dysphagic patients who can swallow safely and return to full oral feeding after 6 weeks of intervention. The study is powered adequately so that this aim can be tested separately for head and neck cancer and stroke patients. Our primary outcome measure is return to oral feeding, i.e., 100% of nutrition and hydration by mouth.

Full description

Secondary aims of this research are:

1. Determine in a descriptive manner whether patients with residue in the pyriform sinuses who aspirate the residue after the swallow respond better, i.e., a higher percentage of them can return to 100% oral intake, than patients with residue in the valleculae who aspirate after the swallow or patients with residue in both locations who aspirate after the swallow and thus to define the spectrum of indications for the proposed exercise programs in the two groups of dysphagic patients (stroke and post-chemo radiation treatment for head and neck cancer) and whether postures enable each patient type to swallow more bolus types without aspiration at pre- and post

2. Define the pathophysiology underlying the swallow dysfunction and those pathophysiologic elements which change as a result of each therapy program including changes in -

   1. anteroposterior and lateral diameter of maximum deglutitive UES opening
   2. maximum deglutitive laryngeal anterior and superior excursions

Sex: All

Ages: 21 to 90 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Inclusion Criteria (all required)

• Patients with pharyngeal phase dysphagia due to stroke or chemoradiation for head and neck cancer (without surgical intervention)
• Incomplete UES opening and post-deglutitive aspiration
• Hypopharyngeal (pyriform sinus) residue or vallecular residue alone or in combination
• Dysphagia requiring tube feeding (at least 3 months non-oral condition)
• Able to comply with protocol mandates, willing to perform the exercise programs, and ability to attend study sessions.

Exclusion Criteria

• Pharyngeal surgical procedures
• Other neuromuscular disorders such as
• Lack of cognition
• Metabolic myopathies
• History of alcoholic neuropathy
• Steroid myopathy
• Cervical spine injury, lesions, or large osteophytes
• Kerns-Sayers Syndrome
• Individuals unable to exercise independently
• Oculo-pharyngeal and other dystrophies
• Current use of anticholinergics:

bensodiazopin, antihistamines

• Myasthenia gravis
• Elimination of aspiration with posture during VFG
• Absent pharyngeal swallow on VFG
• Aspiration before or during the swallow (pre and intradeglutitive aspiration)
• Not completely tube feeding dependent