Dental Photography and Numeric Shade Quantification as a Substitute to Conventional and Instrumental Shade Matching Techniques in the Esthetic Zone

Cairo University (CU)

Status: Enrolling

Conditions: Discoloration, Tooth; Trauma Dental; Non Vital Teeth; Chip Tooth

Treatments: Device: Conventional visual shade matching; Device: Spectrophotometer; Device: Digital photography combined with eLABor_aid shade analyzing software

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT04817579

39920

Details and patient eligibility

About

Visual shade matching is the most common method, in which a color standard from a commercially available dental shade guide is compared to and matched with the target tooth. However, several factors can contribute to perception errors including: different lighting variables, multiple shade systems available in the market with lack of standardization in color systems and corresponding porcelain systems, individual human variables in color perception and lack of understanding of color science.

Therefore, in order to eliminate the uncontrolled variables during the color matching process, instrumental methods have been developed. Spectrophotometric measurement methods employing computer calculations, based on color science and theories, allow quantitative evaluation which is objective and appears to be more accurate. However, extremely high costs, relatively low performance with respect to agreements of the computer-aided devices, and edge loss error make it less acceptable.

One of the most powerful tools in communicating with both patients and dental ceramists is digital photography. Hence, this study is designed to explore the possibilities of a novel approach to shade management (eLABor_aid) utilizing a photocolorimetric (PCM) method and subsequent shade formulation without the use of stock shade guides in comparison to well-known visual and instrumental methods.

The aim of the study is to evaluate the accuracy of digital photography combined with shade analyzing software (eLAB) in optimizing shade matching when compared to conventional and instrumental methods of shade selection.

A Null Hypothesis is suggested where no significant difference regarding shade selection between eLAB protocol, conventional and instrumental methods will be found.

Enrollment: 10 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 20 to 50 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

1. Age range of the patients from 20-50 years old; able to read and sign the informed consent document.
2. Patients able physically and psychologically to tolerate conventional restorative procedures.
3. Patients with no active periodontal or pulpal diseases, having teeth with good restorations.
4. Patients with teeth problems indicated for full coverage restoration (e.g. moderate discoloration, coronal fracture where partial coverage would lack retention, mal-posed or malformed teeth, esthetics enhancement of previously placed crown) where the contralateral/adjacent tooth is present.
5. Patients with root canal treated teeth requiring full coverage restorations even if they need fiber post and core fabrication first.

Exclusion criteria are:

1. Patients with poor oral hygiene and motivation.
2. Patients with teeth with increased incisal translucency.
3. Patients with severe discolored teeth.
4. Patients with smoking habits.
5. Patients with excessive consumption of coffee or tea.
6. Pregnant women to avoid any complication that may occur in dental office due to pregnancy or due to injected anesthetic solution.
7. Patients with psychiatric problems or unrealistic expectation (patient that has phobia from dental treatments or needle injection).
8. Patients suffer from para-functional habits.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Non-Randomized

Interventional model: Crossover Assignment

Masking: Double Blind

---

10 participants in 3 patient groups

Conventional visual shade matching

Active Comparator group

Description:

Patients requiring single crown in the esthetic zone treated with Conventional visual shade matching (Ivoclar Classic shade guide)

Treatment:

Device: Conventional visual shade matching

Spectrophotometer

Experimental group

Description:

Patients requiring single crown in the esthetic zone treated with Spectrophotometer (Vita Easy Shade)

Treatment:

Device: Spectrophotometer

Digital photography combined with eLABor_aid shade analyzing software.

Experimental group

Description:

Patients requiring single crown in the esthetic zone treated with Digital photography combined with eLABor_aid shade analyzing software.

Treatment:

Device: Digital photography combined with eLABor_aid shade analyzing software