Description of Return to Sport in Amateur Athletes Who Underwent Several Functional Tests (K-STARTS, Vertical Jumps and Soleus Muscle Strength) After Initial ACL Reconstruction (K-STARTS +)

GCS Ramsay Santé pour l'Enseignement et la Recherche

Status: Not yet enrolling

Conditions: ACL - Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture

Treatments: Other: Physical tests

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT07249645

2025-A01104-45

Details and patient eligibility

About

ACL injuries are incapacitating for both professional and amateur athletes, with long-term repercussions on performance and return to sport (RTS).

Surgical reconstruction of the ACL is the main treatment option. Despite this, recurrence rates are high. Half of all recurrences occur within 8 months of reconstruction, and 70% within the first 6 months after RTS. Decision to RTS is therefore an important one, as returning too early can increase the risk of recurrence, while returning too late delays a return to pre-injury performance levels. As described by the Bern Consensus, RTS consists of three phases :

• Phase 1: Return to participation (RTp)
• Phase 2: Return to sport (RTS)
• Phase 3: Return to performance (RTP)

RTS decision must be based on multiple factors, including psychological, athletic and functional components, as well as specific nature of the patient's activities. However, few individual tests have been associated with a specific level of RTS. Furthermore, the majority of studies rely on subjective and non-objective assessments to determine whether the athlete has returned to their pre-injury level.

It would therefore be relevant to study the RTS time of patients who have performed a combination of several objective functional tests whose results could be complementary, in particular the K-STARTS, the CMJ, the DJ and the measurement of soleus muscle strength.

Full description

ACL injuries are incapacitating for both professional and amateur athletes, with long-term repercussions on performance and return to sport (RTS). Only 60% of amateurs return to their pre-injury level of performance.

Surgical reconstruction of the ACL is the main treatment option. Despite this, recurrence rates are high (ranging from 17% to 40% depending on the population). Half of all recurrences occur within 8 months of reconstruction, and 70% within the first 6 months after RTS. The decision to RTS is therefore an important one, as returning too early can increase the risk of recurrence, while returning too late delays a return to pre-injury performance levels. As described by the Bern Consensus, RTS consists of three phases (Ardern et al. 2016):

• Phase 1: Return to participation (RTp)
• Phase 2: Return to sport (RTS)
• Phase 3: Return to performance (RTP)

RTS decision must be based on multiple factors, including psychological, athletic and functional components, as well as specific nature of the patient's activities. However, few individual tests have been associated with a specific level of RTS. Furthermore, the majority of studies rely on subjective and non-objective assessments to determine whether the athlete has returned to their pre-injury level. It would therefore be relevant to study the RTS time of patients who have performed a combination of several objective functional tests whose results could be complementary, in particular the K-STARTS, the CMJ, the DJ and the measurement of soleus muscle strength :

• The Knee Santy Athletic Return to Sport (K-STARTS) test, which includes psychological and functional assessments of the knee. The K-STARTS test consists mainly of horizontal jumps that assess the functional capabilities of the knee.
• A. Kotsifaki, et al. (2021) assessed the contribution of the knee joint during various horizontal and vertical jumping tasks. In particular, they reported a greater contribution of the knee during propulsion in vertical vs. horizontal jumps (34.1% vs. 12.9%, respectively) and, conversely, a greater contribution of the knee during landing in horizontal vs. vertical jumps (64.7% vs. 34.3%, respectively). Thus, the combination of vertical and horizontal jumps would allow for a functional assessment of the knee during the different phases of jumping. Counter-Movement Jump (CMJ) and drop jump (DJ) are the main types of vertical jumps recommended for functional assessment of the knee.
• Measurement of soleus muscle strength. Recent studies have shown a decrease in the contribution of the soleus muscle during propulsion and landing in horizontal and vertical jumps in subjects with ACL injury.

Enrollment: 230 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18 to 30 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Patient, male or female, aged between ≥ 18 and ≤ 30 years old
• Amateur athlete with a Tegner score ≥ 5
• Patient with primary ACL reconstruction dating back 6 months
• Patients with ACL damage in one knee only
• Patients who have undergone an isokinetic strength test with results that do not contraindicate functional testing
• Patients affiliated with or covered by a social security scheme
• French-speaking patients who have signed an informed consent form

Exclusion criteria

• Patients treated for bilateral ACL reconstruction
• Patients who are professional athletes or compete at a national level
• Patients with severe associated disorders (neurological, connective tissue, congenital diseases)
• Patients with multiple ligament defects or associated osteotomy
• Patients already included in another study
• Protected patients: adults under guardianship, curatorship or other legal protection, deprived of their liberty by judicial or administrative decision

Trial design

Primary purpose: Basic Science

Allocation: N/A

Interventional model: Single Group Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

230 participants in 1 patient group

K-STARTS +

Experimental group

Description:

K-STARTS + arm involves following tests : K-STARTS, CMJ, DJ and soleus muscle strength measurement

Treatment:

Other: Physical tests