Do Inflammatory Arthritis Inpatients Receiving Group Music Therapy Improve Pain Compared to Music Listening?

University of British Columbia

Status: Completed

Conditions: Spondylarthropathies; Inflammatory Arthritis; Arthritis, Psoriatic; Arthritis, Rheumatoid

Treatments: Other: Music Listening; Other: Music Therapy

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02436785

H14-03446

Details and patient eligibility

About

Pain management is rated by patients with inflammatory arthritis as the highest priority in their disease treatment. Past research showed that music therapy is associated with reduced pain and depression. The purpose of this study is to better understand the effectiveness of music therapy for people with inflammatory arthritis. Participants will be randomly assigned to: 1) Music Therapy group facilitated by a music therapist, or 2) Music Listening group that listens to a relaxation CD (compact disc). Standardized tests will determine if participating in music therapy group helps reduce pain and depression, improve physical function and confidence levels in applying self-management strategies.

Full description

1. Purpose:

   To better understand the effectiveness of music therapy for people with inflammatory arthritis. Determine if participating in a music therapy group facilitated by a music therapist helps reduce pain and depression, and improve physical function and self-efficacy.

   No optional studies are currently planned.

2. Hypothesis Participants in the Music Therapy group will report less pain than those in the Music Listening group after the intervention phase. Music Therapy will also be associated with improvement in secondary outcomes including physical functioning, self-efficacy, and depression.

3. Justification G F Strong Rehabilitation Center Arthritis Inpatient Program has an interdisciplinary approach to pain management: education, medical management, physiotherapy interventions such as exercises and use of physical agents (i.e. heat, cold, electrotherapy, ultrasound), occupational therapy intervention (i.e. activity modification and use of adaptive devices), and social work, dietician, psychology and pharmacy services. Current standard of care has limitations; it insufficiently addresses emotional aspects of chronic pain management. It also introduces relaxation strategies in a didactic module but does not provide training and opportunity to practice these strategies with the support of a health care professional. The Music Therapy intervention group is facilitated by a music therapist. Music therapists are trained to manipulate elements of music to achieve desired effects during music therapy interventions. These elements, such as beat, tempo (speed), or pitch level, can trigger adaptive neurophysiological, psychophysiological, emotional and behavioural responses. The Music Therapy group offers a chance to practice pain management and relaxation strategies, increase a sense of social cohesion and reduce a sense of isolation that individuals may experience when dealing with chronic pain. Participants in the control Music Listening group will listen to a relaxation CD.

   Past research showed that music therapy and music listening are associated with reduced pain intensity levels, increased functional mobility, and reduced depression. There was no clear research found on group music therapy's effectiveness on people with inflammatory arthritis. This feasibility study will help to better understand the effectiveness of music therapy for people with inflammatory arthritis.

4. Objectives

   Outcome measures to be collected include:

   • Category Rating Scale for Pain (from RAPID-3)
   • Rheumatoid Arthritis Self-efficacy Scale (RASE)
   • 6 Minute Walk Test (6MWT)
   • Routine Assessment of Patient Index Data 3 (RAPID-3)
   • Canadian Occupational Performance Measures (COPM)
   • Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) Data will be collected on three occasions: 1) time of enrollment, 2) after attending Music Therapy or Music Listening sessions, and 3) one month after completion of intervention.

5. Research Method

   • Target population: patients with inflammatory arthritis admitted to G F Strong Rehabilitation Center Inpatient Arthritis program
   • Sampling method: participants will be stratified into 4 groups and randomized using a 1:1 allocation ratio into 2 groups: Music Therapy and Music Listening. 40 patients are expected to enroll during recruiting time from April to September in 2015.
   • Research design: Parallel group feasibility randomized controlled trial with a dose-matched active comparator.

6. Statistical Analysis Statistical software such as R, Minitab and Cytel Studio will be used to create descriptive statistics such as means and standard deviations; medians and interquartile ranges, minima, and maxima. A CONSORT flow chart will be constructed to show any losses during the trial, and imputation methods will be used to study the impact of missingness on any of the estimates and conclusions. Statistical models for each outcome variable will be used to measure the effect of Music Therapy compared to Music Listening group. Model assumptions such as independence of observations, normality of residuals and homogeneity of variance to validate the statistical analyses will be conducted.

Enrollment: 13 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 16 to 85 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis
2. Admission to G F Strong Rehabilitation Center Arthritis Inpatient Program from the community or after joint replacement surgery
3. Between ages 16 and 85 years
4. Can speak, read and write in English

Exclusion criteria

1. Self-reported hearing loss
2. Clinician judgement of being unable to follow directions

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

13 participants in 2 patient groups

Music Therapy

Active Comparator group

Description:

The music therapy group will run for approximately an hour (twice a week) and will involve in-vivo relaxation where the live music is manipulated in terms of speed and intensity to bring on a state of relaxation. There will be a brief therapist-led discussion before and after the relaxation portion to increase a sense of group cohesion. Procedures that will be used are based on evidence-based practice for trained Music Therapists.

Treatment:

Other: Music Therapy

Music Listening

Active Comparator group

Description:

The control group will also run for approximately an hour (twice a week) and will involve listening to relaxing music on a CD player.

Treatment:

Other: Music Listening