Early Range of Motion in 5th Metacarpal Fracture

McMaster University

Status: Withdrawn

Conditions: Fracture

Treatments: Behavioral: Early Active Range of Motion; Behavioral: Standard Immobilization

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02441790

NIF-2013-07

Details and patient eligibility

About

Fractures of the fifth metacarpal neck are the most common injury involving the upper extremity. Patients are typically young adult males. Restoring function quickly and reliably for return to work and/or activity is important; these patients are a significant labour force demographic. Treatment is historically splinting for approximately 3-4 weeks. Splinting a fracture is a "trade-off". Immobilization allows stabilization and fracture healing, but also causes hand stiffness and weakness leading to impaired function. Little prospective research exists; there is no agreement for ideal duration of splinting or therapy, demonstrating clinical equipoise. A new concept in hand rehabilitation is "early active range of motion" (EAROM). The objective of this trial is to establish if EAROM provides improved early (6 week) hand function when compared to standard immobilization.

Full description

Fractures of the fifth metacarpal neck ("boxer's fractures"), are the most common injury to the upper extremity. They are the result of axial force on a flexed metacarpalphalangeal (MCP) joint. Typically, they are caused by striking a hard object with a closed fist, breaking the knuckle on the "little" finger. Restoring hand function quickly and reliably for return to work and/or activity is of utmost importance. These patients are a significant labour force demographic. Since the injury is not characteristically sustained at work, "return-to-work"is an important patient consideration for lost wages. Treatment for fractures of the fifth metacarpal neck is typically non-operative. In the absence of urgent operative indications (ie. "open fractures" or contamination), non-operative management is initiated. Closed reduction is performed with local anaesthesia and manual manipulation. A splint is then applied. Repeat x-rays are obtained to determine positioning. If anatomic alignment is stable, no surgery is indicated and the patient remains splinted for 3-4 weeks. "Early active range of motion" (EAROM) refers to actively moving the fractured digit once fracture callus has begun formation at 3 days. In practice, EAROM begins at 3-14 days.It involves controlled, active tendon glide exercises where the patient attempts to move joints in the injured hand. This motion is perpendicular to the fractures pattern, applying a compressive force to the fracture. From basic science models, compressive forces of EAROM improve rate of bone callus differentiation,early healing,fracture angulation and load bearing.This study aims to translate these basic science concepts to practice.

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Age equal or greater than 18 years
2. Fifth metacarpal neck fracture, 9 or fewer days since injury
3. Equal or less than 40 degrees of dorsal fracture angulation on lateral x-ray. Angle is measured between the line along the longitudinal axis of the metacarpal shaft and the line from the centre of the metacarpal head to the fracture site.
4. No angulation or malrotation
5. No clinical fracture shortening (ie. Inability to extend fifth digit)
6. Non-operative treatment
7. Volar or ulnar gutter splint (MCP flexed, IPs extended)

Exclusion criteria

1. Metabolic bone disease
2. "Open fracture" with soft tissue loss overlying fracture site
3. Tendon injury
4. Neurovascular injury
5. Clinical rotatory malalignment
6. Fracture shortening demonstrated by "pseudoclawing"
7. Other fracture in the ipsilateral upper extremity
8. Any operative indication
9. Previous fracture to the involved fifth ray

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

0 participants in 2 patient groups

Early Active Range of Motion

Experimental group

Description:

Early Active Range of Motion (EAROM) 3-9 days following hand fracture

Treatment:

Behavioral: Early Active Range of Motion

Standard Immoblization

Active Comparator group

Description:

Standard immobilization with plaster splint for 21-27 following hand fracture

Treatment:

Behavioral: Standard Immobilization