ECG Monitoring During NRP: a False Sense of Security?

St. Justine's Hospital

Status: Unknown

Conditions: Simulation; Neonatal Resuscitation

Treatments: Diagnostic Test: ECG in delivery room

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT03660033

2019-2022

Details and patient eligibility

About

ECG monitoring is relatively new mode of monitoring in the delivery room. While its use has been positively received by many practitioners of NRP, concerns have been raised about delaying chest compressions for a pulseless baby who may have electrical cardiac activity. It is unknown whether ECG leads do indeed provide a false sense of security in the delivery room. The investigators will be investigating this further using simulation.

Full description

The aim of this study is to evaluate whether the presence of ECG monitoring has an impact on the resuscitative steps of NRP providers.

Participants will be invited to the mother-child simulation center at CHU Sainte-Justine for a 60 minute simulation session during which they will complete two neonatal resuscitation scenarios (one of pulseless VT and the other of PEA). They will be randomized to either having access or not to ECG monitoring during the resuscitations.

Investigators will plan to have participant teams perform the second scenario two weeks after the first scenario. This will be to hopefully mitigate repetition bias, as both scenarios will involve a pulseless newborn.

1. Resuscitation team and equipment Participants will be invited to be part of a three-person resuscitation team (physician or nurse practitioner, respiratory therapist and nurse) to complete the scenarios. A high-fidelity manikin will be utilized in all scenarios (Laerdal © Sim NewB). All necessary equipment as per NRP guidelines for neonatal resuscitation will be present at the bedside for the team to use.

2. Simulation scenarios In each group, the participants will be asked to proceed with the resuscitation of a newborn in the delivery room. Two different rhythms were chosen to see if changes seen with one abnormal appearing rhythm (ventricular tachycardia) can be replicated with a second normal appearing rhythm (PEA). Both of these rhythms cannot be considered normal as the newborn is pulseless.

   For the VT scenario, the newborn will be born in pulseless VT, with a pulse reading of 120 on the ECG monitor. There will have been an uneventful delivery. Participants will be expected to perform defibrillation, endotracheal intubation, chest compressions, umbilical venous catheter placement and intravenous epinephrine. Once the epinephrine is administered, the manikin will have a palpable pulse of 100, which will end the scenario.

   For the PEA scenario, the newborn will have a history of volume loss secondary to placenta previa. Because of the prolonged in utero asphyxia, the baby will be born in PEA arrest, with a heart rate display on the monitor of 80-90. In this scenario, resuscitative steps will include positive pressure ventilation, endotracheal intubation, chest compressions, umbilical venous catheter placement and intravenous epinephrine. Once the epinephrine is administered, the manikin will have a palpable pulse of 100, which will end the scenario.

3. Video recording of scenarios In order to be precise about time measurements, the investigators will record the resuscitations with the help of a video camera. The camera shot will only include the newborn manikin and the resuscitation team's hands. These recordings will not provide any identification data and will be for the sole purpose collecting data for this study. The video will be analyzed by the principal investigator and deleted in accordance with IRB guidelines.

The following data below will be collected. Please note that all time measurements will be from the start of the scenario.

• Time to pulse checks
• Time to application of ECG electrodes (for relevant scenarios)
• Number of subsequent pulse checks after application of ECG electrodes
• Method of pulse check (auscultation, palpation of the umbilical cord or brachial pulse)
• Time to start of chest compressions
• Time to administration of epinephrine

A questionnaire for each participant will collect the following data prior to the simulations: occupation, number of years of training in neonatology, number of years of experience in neonatology, last NRP course and approximate number of resuscitations in past year.

Enrollment: 60 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 21+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Regular providers of neonatal resuscitation at our institution
• This includes residents, fellows, neonatal nurse practitioners, attending physicians, transport nurses and respiratory therapists
• Consents to the study (through a process of recruitment and informed consent)

Exclusion criteria

• Any individual who does not regularly participate in neonatal resuscitation in the delivery room
• Any individual who refuses consent

Trial design

Primary purpose: Other

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Single Group Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

60 participants in 2 patient groups

With ECG

Experimental group

Description:

These teams will have access to ECG monitoring (intervention) during the scenario

Treatment:

Diagnostic Test: ECG in delivery room

Without ECG

No Intervention group

Description:

These teams will NOT have access to ECG monitoring during the scenario