Estonia's Enhanced Care Management Impact Evaluation (ECM)

President and Fellows of Harvard College

Status: Completed

Conditions: Multi-morbidity; Non-communicable Diseases

Treatments: Behavioral: Enhanced Care Management

Study type: Observational

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT05829642

P169891

Details and patient eligibility

About

Estonia's aging population faces an increasing burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) and a growing population suffers with multiple chronic conditions. These changes have reduced well-being and quality of life for many older Estonians, while increasing the use of high cost specialist and emergency care. In response, the Estonia Health Insurance Fund (EHIF) is working to support primary care physicians to improve care for complex patients with multiple chronic conditions. A new EHIF-led program, Enhanced Care Management (ECM), entails training family physicians to identify complex patients, co-develop proactive care plans with them, and to undertake more active outreach to and management of these patients.

Full description

The Enhanced Care Management (ECM) intervention consists of training and coaching family physicians and their teams to develop holistic care and pro-active outreach plans for chronically ill patients or those vulnerable to developing chronically illnesses, as identified and agreed between the enrolled providers and the Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF). Under ECM, patients covered by EHIF and suffering from chronic diseases such as diabetes and cardiovascular diseases will be proactively engaged and monitored by primary care providers to provide better care and to prevent health deterioration.

Risk-stratified care management for chronic conditions was first introduced in Estonia in 2017 to better support high-risk patients with an assortment of chronic conditions and an increased risk of healthcare utilization. The Enhanced Care Management (ECM) program is intended to improve the quality of care provided to complex patients with qualifying chronic conditions, by increasing the use of preventive care, improving coordination of care across health system levels, and increasing patient involvement in care. These elements can improve patient health and quality of life, and may reduce the need for curative and higher-level medical services-for example, by supporting patients with type 2 diabetes to improve their diet and increase physical activity to limit further deterioration in their health and use of emergency or specialty health services.

In 2017, the World Bank, EHIF and the Estonian Family Physicians Association launched a pilot of risk-stratified care management with a very small number of volunteering primary health care providers. From January to February 2017, a digital environment was developed to monitor patients for family physicians. It contains important data of risk patients (health indicators, medical history, socio-economic background) which can be accessed digitally by health care providers. This allowed family physicians and nurses to monitor health indicators and treatment goals of high-risk patients and track the implementation of the treatment plan.

The family physician and nurse's responsibilities involved assessing patient needs, creating treatment plans, coordinating health-related activities, and working with a social worker to provide social support. During the pilot project, family physicians collaborated with hospitals to track patient outcomes. Results of the initial pilot convinced EHIF that it would be beneficial to test expansion of the ECM model nationally, so a full-scale study was launched during 2020 to include a representative sample of clinics and their eligible patients nationwide.

In this study, the research team will conduct a randomized controlled trial in partnership with EHIF to evaluate the impact of ECM training for physicians. The RCT will have enrolled a randomly selected 97 family physicians out of the 786 family physicians practicing in Estonia. Among those physicians' 6,739 ECM-eligible patients, 2,389 patients will have been randomly selected for enrollment into the ECM program. Using administrative records, the study will evaluate the effects of ECM enrollment on: (1) health care utilization; (2) provider management of tracer conditions; and (3) markers of quality of care such as hospital admission for primary health care-sensitive conditions.

Enrollment: 2,389 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

• identified by general practitioner as having multiple chronic health conditions including type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and obesity

Exclusion Criteria (for patients):

• terminal illness; acute cancer (cancer in treatment), schizophrenia, dialysis due to renal failure, congenital malformations requiring specialized care, and rare diseases; patients with more than 7 chronic conditions

Exclusion Criteria (for clinics) Having participated in ECM pilot study; not being currently operational; or having five or more practicing providers in the clinic

Trial design

2,389 participants in 2 patient groups

ECM intervention arm

Description:

The Enhanced Care Management (ECM) intervention consists of training and coaching family physicians and their teams to develop holistic care and pro-active outreach plans for chronically ill patients or those vulnerable to developing chronically illnesses, as identified and agreed between the enrolled providers and the Estonian Health Insurance Fund (EHIF). The core goal of ECM is to improve the quality of care provided to complex patients, including by increasing the use of preventive care, improving coordination of care across health system levels, and increasing patient involvement in care. These elements can improve patient health and quality of life, and may reduce the need for curative medical services.

Treatment:

Behavioral: Enhanced Care Management

Control

Description:

The control group will not receive any intervention.