Exercise + Self-Compassion Intervention for Depression

Western University, Canada

Status: Completed

Conditions: Depression

Treatments: Behavioral: Self-compassion psychoeducation; Behavioral: Behavioural Coaching; Other: Exercise

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT04572035

2020-0000-E

Details and patient eligibility

About

An alarming number of students report depressive symptoms that make it difficult to function academically. Previous research has indicated that exercise can be effective in treating mild-moderate depression. However, individuals with depression may struggle psychologically to adhere to exercise programs. Researchers have highlighted the potential role of self-compassion, a psychological approach that is useful in dealing with personal inadequacies, to facilitate health behaviour regulation. Behavioural coaching is another approach that consists of self-regulatory strategies such as action planning and less emphasis on emotion-focused strategies. The purpose of this study is to test the effectiveness of a structured exercise and psychoeducation program on improving depressive symptoms among inactive students with depression and to evaluate if the addition of psychological components (self-compassion or behavioural coaching) affects this effectiveness. Students with mild-to-moderate depression will refer themselves to participate or be referred/recommended by Student Health Services at Western University. The study will consist of attending 3 exercise + psychoeducation sessions per week for 10-weeks. Study participants will be randomly allocated to one of three groups; exercise only, exercise + self-compassion, or exercise + behavioral coaching. All will complete questionnaires before, after, and 3-months following the end of their sessions. It is expected that participants in the exercise + self-compassion or exercise + behaviour coaching groups will show greater improvements in their depressive symptoms, program adherence and follow-up exercise behaviour and depression after 3 months than the exercise only group and that the exercise + self-compassion group will be superior to the exercise + behavioural coaching group in those measurements.

Full description

This is a 10-week randomized parallel study assessing the effectiveness of exercise in reducing depressive symptoms among students with mild-to-moderate depression. This study has three treatment arms: exercise; exercise + self-compassion; exercise + behavioral coaching. Each participant will be invited to attend 3 supervised group-based sessions each week either virtually through Zoom or in-person at the Exercise and Health Psychology Lab for 10 weeks. Senior undergraduate Kinesiology students will facilitate a personalized exercise program adapted to the participant's abilities, teach participants how to exercise, and gauge exercise intensity in a safe manner. The CANMAT guidelines will be implemented, with the program consisting of supervised moderate-intensity exercise sessions lasting 30-minutes (plus 10-minutes for warm-up and cool-down), 3 times weekly, for a period of 10-weeks. Participants will start exercising at a low intensity and progressively increase until they are consistently exercising at a moderate intensity. The exercise intervention will integrate moderate intensity aerobic and resistance training activities while accounting for the physical abilities and interests of the individual participant and theh group.The exercise + psychoeducation groups will receive equal contact supplemental individual manualized strategies each session (+15-20 minutes) centered either on behaviour change strategies (i.e., action planning, implementation intentions, relapse prevention, and goal setting) or self-compassion strategies (i.e., mindfulness, self-directed kindness meditations, and writing tasks). The manualized psychoeducation sessions will be group-based with the trainer that is supervising the exercise sessions. Participants will fill out surveys before, after and three months following the intervention period.

Enrollment: 60 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 17 to 30 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

Informed of the nature of the study and have agreed to and are able to read, review, and sign the informed consent form. The informed consent document will be written in English; therefore, the volunteer must have the ability to read and communicate in English.

• Student participants 17 to 30 years of age, inclusive, at the time of screening.
• Available and able to attend 3x group-based exercise training sessions per week.
• Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ)-9 score of >5
• Godin Leisure-Time Exercise Questionnaire score of <14
• Able to engage in physical activity as assessed by the PAR-Q
• For Virtual Intervention Only: access to reliable internet connection and computer with a camera for the purpose of the Zoom Video calls

Exclusion criteria

• Participant receives pharmacological (i.e. medications listed in list of prohibited medications document) or psychotherapy treatment for depression or anxiety
• Reports of suicide ideation (e.g., PHQ-9 item) and scores on the PHQ-9 >20 demonstrating severe depression
• Failed safety screening for exercise without physician clearance
• Participant initiates pharmacological or psychotherapy treatments for depression while in the study and/or participates in any other research that aims to target depression

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

60 participants in 3 patient groups

Exercise only

Experimental group

Description:

Undergraduate peer-facilitators part of a curricular kinesiology program will facilitate a personalized group-based exercise program adapted to the participant's abilities, teach participants how to exercise, and gauge exercise intensity in a safe manner (26). The CANMAT guidelines will be implemented, with the program consisting of supervised group-based moderate-intensity exercise sessions lasting 30-minutes (plus 10-minutes for warm-up and cool-down), 3 times weekly, for a period of 10-weeks. Participants will start exercising at a low intensity and progressively increase until they are consistently exercising at a moderate intensity. As a result of the uncertainty surrounding the pandemic, the intervention will be conducted either via a virtual platform or in-person at the Exercise and Health Psychology Lab, depending on the health and safety restrictions applicable to when the student enrolls and begins their program.

Treatment:

Other: Exercise

Exercise + Self-compassion

Experimental group

Description:

Participants will undergo the same exercise program as described in the exercise only treatment arm. Participants will receive equal contact supplemental individual manualized strategies each session (+15-20 minutes) centered on self-compassion strategies (i.e., mindfulness, self-directed kindness meditations, and writing tasks).

Treatment:

Behavioral: Self-compassion psychoeducation

Other: Exercise

Exercise + Behavioural Coaching

Experimental group

Description:

Participants will undergo the same exercise program as described in the exercise only treatment arm. Participants will receive equal contact supplemental individual manualized strategies each session (+15-20 minutes) centered on behaviour change strategies (i.e., action planning, implementation intentions, relapse prevention, and goal setting).

Treatment:

Behavioral: Behavioural Coaching

Other: Exercise