Exploring the Outcomes of System Supports for Youth With Mental Illness and/or Addictions and Their Families

Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre

Status: Completed

Conditions: Mental Health Disorder; Addiction

Treatments: Other: Resource List; Other: Navigation

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT03765281

040-2018

Details and patient eligibility

About

This trial (Phase II) will assess the different methods of supporting families in finding mental health and/or addictions (MHA) services for youth. Youth with MHA issues and their families are particularly vulnerable in the MHA system, due to a lack of specialized support and complicated transitions between services. This study will assess the potential impact of Navigation on youth MHA symptom reduction or functional improvement, family functioning, satisfaction with MHA services, as well as the cost-benefit of Navigation. This project will seek to determine whether there is a difference for those youth with MHA issues and their families who receive Navigation over those who find and access MHA care on their own.

Full description

This pilot feasibility trial (Phase I) assessed the feasibility to conduct a randomized controlled trial examining whether families of youth ages 13 to 26 with mental illness and/or addiction concerns who receive Navigation services experience improved clinical outcomes compared to families who interact with the MHA care system on their own (usual care). This pilot feasibility trial (Phase I) assessed the different methods of supporting families in finding mental health and/or addictions (MHA) services for youth. Youth with MHA issues and their families are particularly vulnerable in the MHA system, due to a lack of specialized support and complicated transitions between services. This study assessed the potential impact of Navigation on youth MHA symptom reduction or functional improvement, family functioning, satisfaction with MHA services, as well as the cost-benefit of Navigation and sought to determine whether there is a difference for those youth with MHA issues and their families who receive Navigation over those who find and access MHA care on their own.

The primary outcomes for Phase I of this trial were:

1. Recruitment rate as a measure of recruitment feasibility (baseline): tracking of recruitment rate to determine whether it is high enough for a full-scale trial to be feasible.
2. Change in acceptability of study methods across time (two months and four months): Acceptability of Procedures and assessments by participants as measure of protocol feasibility (Questionnaire developed based on the Theoretical Framework of Acceptability, Sekhon et al., 2017).
3. Study Completion Rate (four months): tracking of study completion rate to determine whether it is high enough for a full-scale trial to be feasible.

The secondary outcomes for Phase I of this trial were:

1. Caregiver Strain Across Time (baseline, two months, four months): Caregiver Strain Questionnaire as measure of functional and health outcomes for the youth and family (CSQ; Bickman et al., 2012). Clinical Outcome #1.
2. Youth Symptoms & Functioning Across Time (baseline, two months and four months): Symptoms and Functioning Severity Scale (SFSS, Bickman et al., 2012).Clinical Outcome #2.Total Scale Range= Min: 26, Max: 130. Higher values = worst outcome.
3. Family Functioning Across Time (baseline, two months and four months) (baseline, two months and four months): Olson Family Satisfaction Scale (FSS, Olson, 2010). Clinical Outcome #3. Total Scale range = Min: 10, Max: 50. High values = better outcome.
4. Youth Emotion & Behaviour Symptoms Across Time (baseline and four months): Child and Adolescent Symptom Inventory (CASI, Sprafkin et al., 2010). Clinical Outcome #4. Total Scale Range = Min 29, Max: 87. Higher values = worst outcome.
5. Caregiver Quality of Life Across Time (baseline and four months): Medical Outcomes Survey Short-Form (SF-36, RAND Health, 2018). Clinical Outcome #5. Total Scale Range = Min: 36, Max: 180. Higher values = worst outcome.
6. Youth Quality of Life Across Time (baseline and four months): Medical Outcomes Survey Short-Form (SF-36; RAND Health, 2018). Clinical Outcome #6. Total Scale Range = Min: 36, Max: 180. Higher values = worst outcome.

Other outcome measures:

1. Health Services Utilization over time (baseline and four months): Health Services Utilization Questionnaire (Henderson et al., 2017) Reporting of usage of health services for purposes of cost change estimates.
2. Health Services Utilization over time (baseline and four months): Child and Adolescent Services Assessment (CASA; Ascher et al., 1996); Reporting of access of health services for services usage estimates.

Enrollment: 207 patients

Sex: All

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• family member of youth age 13 to 26 who is experiencing a mental health concern and/or substance use issue
• residing in the Greater Toronto Area
• seeking mental health and/or addictions services or supports

Exclusion criteria

• currently in crisis
• previously received navigation support at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Health Services Research

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Triple Blind

---

207 participants in 2 patient groups

Navigation

Experimental group

Description:

Navigation intervention plus Resource List

Treatment:

Other: Navigation

Other: Resource List

Self-Navigation

Active Comparator group

Description:

Resource List intervention

Treatment:

Other: Resource List