Impact of Early Post-Operative Water Exposure on Complications of Cutaneous Surgeries

Penn State Health

Status: Completed

Conditions: Surgical Wound Infection

Treatments: Behavioral: Early Water Exposure

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT01773694

HMC IRB 38335EP

Details and patient eligibility

About

Patients are often counseled to keep a surgical wound dry for 2 to 3 days. The rationale is likely to decrease the risk of infection and bleeding. However, this has never been formally studied. Patient's routines are likely disrupted when they are asked to avoid wetting the area. The investigators will perform a controlled study to determine if avoidance of post-operative wetting is necessary.

Full description

Physicians commonly instruct their patients to keep a wound dry for 2 to 3 days following surgery. The rationale may be that sources of water like a shower, bathtub, or swimming pool may increase the risk of infection. There may also be a concern that changing a dressing in the early post-operative period will increase the risk of bleeding complications. However, patient's routines and quality of life are disrupted when they are asked to avoid bathing, exercise, and swimming.

These issues have never been formally studied. This study will test the hypothesis of whether early post-operative wetting will have any influence on infection rates, bleeding complications, or the appearance of a surgical wound. Patients presenting to the Penn State Hershey dermatology clinic for the surgical removal of cancerous or non-cancerous skin lesions will be invited to participate. There will be no change to the standard surgical treatment. The dressing will be the same for all study participants. After surgery, study subjects who consent to participate will be randomized to receive one of two sets of post-operative instructions. One group will be directed to keep their initial post-operative dressing intact and dry for 48 hours. The second group will remove the dressing at 6 hours and wet the wound for 10 minutes in whatever manner they choose (shower, bath, pool, hot tub, etc.). After the initial dressing is removed (at 48 hours or 6 hours), both groups will perform identical post-operative care, consisting of cleansing the wound with soap and water followed by the application of petrolatum ointment and a dry dressing.

All participants will follow-up 7 to 14 days after surgery or earlier if they are experiencing any problems. At this time, the site will be assessed for clinical evidence of infection and bleeding. If the former is present, a bacterial culture will be obtained to confirm a wound infection and patients will be treated with an antibiotic. Physicians performing the assessment will be blinded to the patient's status (early wetting group or not). All subjects will also complete a questionnaire inquiring how and when they wet their wounds after surgery as well as two questionnaires asking how their quality-of-life and function were affected. Participants will again follow-up at 6 months when a blinded investigator will assess the cosmetic appearance of the scars using an established scar rating tool.

The data from this study will provide valuable evidence based guidance to surgeons in drafting wound care instructions for their patients. If the hypothesis proves correct, patients may be spared the inconvenience of post-operative water avoidance, diminishing the disruption to their lives caused by skin surgery.

Enrollment: 507 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. subjects are capable of giving informed consent

2. patients undergoing any surgical treatment of benign and malignant lesions by any physician in the Dermatology department consisting of:

   1. standard excisional surgery or Mohs micrographic surgery with immediate reconstruction
   2. reconstruction with primary linear closure or adjacent tissue transfer with one or two layers of suture

Exclusion criteria

1. pregnancy
2. age younger than 18 years
3. will not be returning to the dermatology clinic in 7-14 days for suture removal
4. documented or suspected infection of the site prior to surgery
5. current treatment with systemic antibiotic therapy
6. staged excisions
7. delayed or staged reconstructions
8. wounds repaired with skin or cartilage grafts
9. management with secondary intention healing
10. surgical site on or near a mucosal surface where standard dressings are not typically used (eyelid, vermilion, etc.)
11. patients receiving prophylactic antibiotics
12. patients deemed on a case-by-case basis by their surgeon to have a high risk of post-operative bleeding and requiring prolonged application of a pressure dressing
13. history of skin sensitivity or reaction to white petrolatum

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Triple Blind

---

507 participants in 2 patient groups

Early Water Exposure

Active Comparator group

Description:

The Intervention group will receive written and verbal instructions to remove the dressing after 6 hours and wet the wound for at least 10 minutes. Wetting of the wound will include shower, tub bath, or pool exposure.

Treatment:

Behavioral: Early Water Exposure

Standard Care

No Intervention group

Description:

The Standard Care group will receive standard wound care instructions and verbal education by the staff to keep the dressing dry and intact for 48 hours.