Intermittent Auscultation Using Handheld Doppler: a Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Perinatal Outcomes in Uganda

The Hospital for Sick Children

Status: Completed

Conditions: Neonatal Death; Stillbirth

Treatments: Procedure: Partograph; Device: Fetal heart rate Doppler

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02273037

1000031587

Details and patient eligibility

About

A novel handheld Doppler has been developed which is rugged and is powered only by a hand crank. This study aims to test the use of this Doppler versus the Pinard horn to monitor the fetal heart rate in labour in a hospital setting in Uganda. The investigators propose that with its ease of use, both for the woman and midwife, midwives using the Doppler will identify more babies in need of prompt delivery and the risk of stillbirth and neonatal mortality will decline. In the research study, the investigators will compare the risk of stillbirths and neonatal mortality in two randomized groups of labouring women.

The second part of the study consists of an audit of the documentation in labour by midwives. The partograph is an uncomplicated, low cost form on which observations during labour are documented. It includes three sections of information: fetal condition, maternal condition and labour progress. Although the use of a partograph during labour is strongly recommended by the WHO, there are limited published systematic evaluations of the correct use of the tool. The investigators aim to use this randomized trial design to assess rates of intrapartum stillbirth and neonatal mortality in the first 24 hours after delivery, and assess the quality of partographs comparing two groups.

This trial will provide insights on the potential benefits of using handheld Doppler devices for intrapartum monitoring, and the audit of partograph quality will provide insights to improve care during labour. This study hypothesizes that the quality of partograph completion and of fetal heart rate monitoring may systematically differ between the Doppler and Pinard groups.

Full description

1. Objectives:

   1. To evaluate the intervention of a wind-up, handheld Doppler fetal heart rate monitor (Doppler) and to identify implementation challenges;
   2. To identify process issues and the impact of the Doppler on rates of intrapartum stillbirth and neonatal deaths within 24 hours, in comparison to use of the Pinard horn (current practice);
   3. To assess the quality of partographs using a standardized scoring system to audit overall completion and quality, and fetal heart rate monitoring specifically; we will compare the audit results between partographs where monitoring was done with the Pinard horn versus the Doppler. The hypothesis being that the quality of partograph completion and of fetal heart rate monitoring may systematically differ between these two groups;
   4. To build the research capacity of Ugandan midwives by facilitating their participation in this research study.

2. Study design

   Equal randomization clinical trial to compare Pinard horn (current practice) versus Doppler (intervention) to monitor the fetal heart in labour.

3. Characteristics of the study population

   1. Number of participants Based on the results of a randomized controlled trial in urban Zimbabwe in 1994 [Mahomed, BMJ], the investigators hypothesize that use of a handheld Doppler fetal heart monitor will reduce the rate of intrapartum stillbirth by at least 30% compared to monitoring fetal heart rate with a Pinard horn. With 80% power to detect at least a 30% reduction in stillbirths with 95% confidence, 840 labouring women would need to be enrolled in each of the two comparison groups. Adding 20% to allow for losses to follow-up and statistical adjustments/stratification, 1008 labouring women are required for each comparison group.
   2. Location of the research The study will be conducted in the San Raphael of St Francis Hospital Nsambya Hospital, in Uganda. This is a general hospital and maternity located in the peri-urban region of Kampala City. It is a private not-for-profit institution with 7,500 annual deliveries. In addition, it offers training for residents, intern doctors, nurses, midwives and technicians.

4. Data analysis The investigators will review the partograph and record their findings on a tool developed for this purpose. The data that will be recorded will be of statistical nature but at the bottom of each Partograph Assessment Tool is space for qualitative comments from the reviewer. Besides date of birth and the patient file identity number no data will be recorded which can reveal the identity of the patient. This is to ensure patient privacy and confidentiality of the data, without losing the possibility to retrieve the file from medical records if needed. After recording the data on a hard copy in the hospital, the data will be entered twice into the statistical package before analysis. The information that this will give will be descriptively analysed. The proportion and incidence risk rate of participants who experience each fetal outcome under study and the mean partograph scores will be compared between the intervention and control groups.

Enrollment: 1,987 patients

Sex: Female

Volunteers: Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• All mothers presenting to the labour wards in labour with a singleton pregnancy above 37 completed weeks of gestation, and cephalic presentation
• All mothers admitted to the labour ward for monitoring of active phase of labour with a live intrauterine fetus

Exclusion criteria

• Mothers admitted to the labour wards with a pregnancy gestation age below 37 weeks
• Mothers admitted with a diagnosis of intra uterine fetal death
• Mothers presenting in second stage of labour
• Mothers with a high risk pregnancy eg pre eclampsia, ante partum hemorrhage
• Mothers being admitted for an elective caesarean section

Trial design

Primary purpose: Diagnostic

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

1,987 participants in 2 patient groups, including a placebo group

Pinard horn

Placebo Comparator group

Description:

Pinard horn (current practice) used to monitor the fetal heart rate in labour in this arm of the study.

Treatment:

Procedure: Partograph

Fetal heart rate Doppler

Experimental group

Description:

Doppler used to monitor the fetal heart rate in labour in this arm of the study.

Treatment:

Device: Fetal heart rate Doppler

Procedure: Partograph