Manual Therapy to Treat Gluteus Medius Trigger Points

Mitchell Selhorst

Status: Terminated

Conditions: Anterior Knee Pain Syndrome; Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome

Treatments: Other: Placebo Control; Other: Hip and core strengthening exercises; Other: Dry Needling; Other: Soft Tissue Mobilization

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02333617

IRB14-00621

Details and patient eligibility

About

This is a blinded randomized controlled trial to assess the effectiveness of manual therapy to improve hip abduction strength in patients with acute anterior knee pain.

The primary objective of this study is to see if manual therapy to the gluteus medius can significantly alter within-session measurements of hip abductor strength in patients with anterior knee pain.

The secondary objective of this study is to see if manual therapy to the gluteus medius can significantly alter within session pain in patients with anterior knee pain.

Full description

People with anterior knee pain have significant hip abductor muscle weakness compared to healthy people (Prins, 2009). Hip abductor weakness has a strong correlation with impaired lower extremity mechanics and increased pain with functional activity (Stickler et al. 2014). A study by Roach et al in 2013 found that 97% of patients with anterior knee pain had a trigger point in their gluteus medius muscle, while only 23% of healthy controls had trigger points. Trigger points alter normal muscle activity and increase pain in patients (Lucas, 2010, Ibarra et al 2011). Hip abduction strengthening has been found to significantly decrease pain and improve function in patients with anterior knee pain (Earl, 2011). By decreasing trigger points in the gluteus medius the investigators may be able to increase hip abduction strength reducing pain and dysfunction in patients with anterior knee pain.

Both Dry Needling (DN) and Soft Tissue Mobilization (STM) are manual therapy interventions commonly used by physical therapist to decrease trigger points in muscles. Currently, no research has examined the effectiveness of manual therapy to treat trigger points and improve hip abductor strength in patients with anterior knee pain. Clinically, the investigators have noted that after a patient has been treated with STM or DN that the investigators see immediate improvements in hip abduction strength. The investigators do not know if noted improvements result from repeated strength testing practice or actual improved firing strength of muscles.

The primary objective of this study is to see if manual therapy to the gluteus medius can significantly alter within-session measurements of hip abductor strength in patients with anterior knee pain.

The secondary objective of this study is to see if manual therapy to the gluteus medius can significantly alter within session pain in patients with anterior knee pain.

Patients referred to our physical therapy clinic for anterior knee pain will be considered for this study. After explaining the study and answering any patient or parent questions, informed consent will be obtained for those individuals wishing to participate. The participants will be screened to see if they meet the inclusion criteria, and will be randomly to a treatment group (Dry Needling, Soft Tissue Mobilization, Placebo control). This will be a single blinded research study with the assessor being blinded to the intervention. The therapist who performs the hip abductor strength measurements will not be the same therapist who performs the experimental interventions. The patient cannot be blinded to the treatment that they receive. The therapist performing the intervention will open a sealed envelope that allocates patient to Dry Needling, Soft Tissue Mobilization, or Sham Needling group. Following the experimental intervention all patients will perform the same hip and core exercise protocol.

Pre-treatment evaluation measures will be taken on the patient blinded assessor.

These will consist of:

• Hand held dynamometer hip abduction strength measurements.
• Pain with single leg squat

The subject will then receive the appropriate treatment based on his/her random assignment to experimental treatment groups by the treating therapist.

Post-treatment evaluation measures will be taken on all patients by the blinded assessor immediately following treatment. These will be the same measures taken pre-treatment.

• Hand held dynamometer hip abduction strength measurements.
• Pain with single leg squat Patients will then perform the same hip and core exercise protocol, Following these exercises Post-Exercise evaluation measures by the blinded assessor. These will be the same measures taken pre-treatment.

Enrollment: 3 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 13+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Acute anterior knee pain of <90days

• Ipsilateral hip abductor weakness of >15%

  • 2/10 pain with single leg squat

Exclusion criteria

• Contraindication to dry needling or soft tissue mobilization
• Non-mechanical anterior knee pain
• Fear of needles

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

3 participants in 3 patient groups, including a placebo group

Dry Needling and Exercise

Experimental group

Description:

Dry Needling to treat gluteus medius trigger points followed by hip and core exercises.

Treatment:

Other: Dry Needling

Other: Hip and core strengthening exercises

Soft Tissue Mobilization

Active Comparator group

Description:

Soft tissue mobilization to treat gluteus medius trigger points followed by hip and core exercises.

Treatment:

Other: Hip and core strengthening exercises

Other: Soft Tissue Mobilization

Placebo Control

Placebo Comparator group

Description:

Placebo to control for hands on time and attention from therapist followed by hip and core exercises.

Treatment:

Other: Placebo Control

Other: Hip and core strengthening exercises