Mindfulness Self-Compassion Intervention Versus a Cognitive-Behavioral Intervention to Improve Self-care in Chronic Pain

Instituto de Investigación Hospital Universitario La Paz

Status: Completed

Conditions: Chronic Pain

Treatments: Behavioral: CBT; Behavioral: MSC

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT03386422

1

Details and patient eligibility

About

Approximately 10-23% of people suffer from chronic pain in our country. Chronic pain is associated with emotional distress (anxiety and depression), physical and social impairment and reduction of quality of life in patients who suffer from this condition.

Self-Compassion is a useful attitude in order to regulate emotions, to be able to accept the experience that one is going through and to improve self-care in general population. Cognitive-behavioral programs (CBT) have already demonstrated that they are effective in order to reduce catastrophizing and passive coping with pain. However, effects of Mindful Self-Compassion interventions (based on mindfulness skills but not only) on chronic pain condition are still unknown.

The investigator's principal hypothesis is: MSC program will be, at least, as effective as CBT program in order to improve quality of life, self-compassion, self-care and acceptance capacity; and as effective as CBT to reduce catastrophizing, anxiety and depression in a chronic pain patients sample.

Moreover, investigators also hypothesize that MSC program will be, at least, as effective as CBT program in order to maintain the achieved benefits in a 6 months follow-up.

Investigators will conduct a Randomized Controlled Trial with two treatment arms in a chronic pain sample of patients of Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid.

After all recollection of data is done, investigators will conduct statistic analysis in order to accept or refuse our hypothesis.

Full description

Approximately 10-23% of people suffer from chronic pain in our country. Chronic pain is associated with emotional distress (anxiety and depression), physical and social impairment and reduction of quality of life in patients who suffer from this condition.

Recent studies have elucidated that some conditions are clearly correlated with chronic pain, and could explain emotional distress and impairment in these patients. Such conditions are: attention bias to pain, cognitive inflexibility, fear avoidance, catastrophizing, passive coping with pain and no acceptance.

Recent meta-analysis suggest that Mindfulness-based interventions reduce anxiety and pain interference in daily life in patients with chronic pain. They do so through mechanisms that improve capacity of acceptance (whatever the experience is) and reduce catastrophizing. Self-Compassion is a useful attitude in order to regulate emotions, to be able to accept the experience that one is going through and to improve self-care in general population. Cognitive-behavioral programs (CBT) have already demonstrated that they are effective in order to reduce catastrophizing and passive coping with pain. However, effects of Mindful Self-Compassion interventions (based on mindfulness skills but not only) on chronic pain condition are still unknown.

Neff and Germer have developed a specific program to enhance self-compassion named Mindful Self-Compassion (MSC) that could be helpful to people with clinical problems. In spite of promising results of this interventions based on acceptation and self-compassion, its effectiveness on chronic pain conditions remains still unclear.

Investigator's principal hypothesis is: MSC program will be, at least, as effective as CBT program in order to improve quality of life, self-compassion, self-care and acceptance capacity; and as effective as CBT to reduce catastrophizing, anxiety and depression in a chronic pain patients sample.

Moreover, investigators also hypothesize that MSC program will be, at least, as effective as CBT program in order to maintain the achieved benefits in a 6 months follow-up.

Investigators will conduct a Randomized Controlled Trial with two treatment arms in a chronic pain sample of patients of Hospital Universitario La Paz, Madrid.

Both interventions will have 8 sessions, weekly frequency, duration of 2 hours and a half per session, and both programs will be conducted by clinical experts.

Investigators will asses levels of anxiety, depression, catastrophizing, pain interference, pain intensity, self-compassion and quality of life at the beginning of the intervention, at the end of the intervention, and a 6 months follow-up. Investigators also will administer a socio-demographic questionnaire at the beginning of the intervention to collect data about age, gender and pain characteristics.

After all recollection of data is done, investigators will conduct statistic analysis in order to accept or refuse their hypothesis.

Enrollment: 159 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Older than 18 years old.
• Being in treatment in the Chronic Pain Unit at Hospital Universitario La Paz because of having a chronic pain of more than 3 months of duration, no matter the aetiology.
• Capable of understanding and giving his or her written informed consent.
• Significant levels of distress related to the pain at the beginning of treatment, assessed by clinical interview and HADS (HADS-A or HADS-D > or = 8).
• Patients that meet criteria for Mixed Adaptive Disorder, mild to moderate Depressive Disorder or Dysthymia, assessed by clinical interview conducted by a psychiatry of the Chronic Pain Unit or Mental Health Center.

Exclusion criteria

• Intelectual disability or cognitive impairment or dementia.
• Insufficient knowledge of the language to understand and participate on the intervention program.
• Serious mental illness in acute state at the moment of the beginning of the intervention.
• Substance abuse in the last 6 months.
• Autolytic ideas at the moment of the assessment.
• Previous training in mindfulness or CBT techniques.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Supportive Care

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

159 participants in 2 patient groups

Mindfulness Self-Compassion Intervention MSC

Experimental group

Description:

Mindfulness Self-Compassion (MSC) is a standardized program to increase self-compassion. It has been developed by Neff and Germer. The structure of the program is similar to de Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction program (MBSR), with duration of sessions between 2 and 2 hours and a half. The frequency of the sessions is one per week for 8 weeks, with practical and experiential exercices in sessions and between sessions. The MSC program focuses primary on helping patients to develop self-compassion, and it includes Mindfulness just as a secondary component. The MSC program will be conducted by a clinician trained in this specific program.

Treatment:

Behavioral: MSC

Cognitive-Behavioural Intervention CBT

Active Comparator group

Description:

It has been adapted a Cognitive-Behavioural Intervention for Chronic Pain by Moix and Kovacs. Our program will have 8 sessions, with duration of sessions between 2 and 2 hours and a half. The frequency of the sessions is one per week for 8 weeks, with homework between sessions. During these 8 sessions we will train the following techniques: psychoeducation about pain, relaxation training, cognitive restructuring training, solving problem training, psychoeducation about emotions, interpersonal skills and time organization.

Treatment:

Behavioral: CBT