Status
Conditions
Treatments
About
What is this trial ? A major aim in surgery is to consent patients appropriately for procedures. This is known as shared decision making. It is the clinician's duty to provide patients with the information they need to weigh up the risks and benefits of surgery and come to an informed decision. The investigators have created a patient information course on bariatric surgery on a platform known as a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC). This platform will host the course and will involve videos, written material and a number of questions to test the patient's understanding. The course will be undertaken after patients have completed Tier 3 and been discussed at the Tier 4 MDT (multidisciplinary team) and before the first consultant appointment to discuss surgical options.
If patients choose to participate, they will be randomly allocated to either undertake the patient information course or not to undertake the course and just undergo the standard consenting process.
The actual timeline of the bariatric journey will be unaffected by participation in the trial. The consultant will not know of patient participation and patients will be asked not to disclose it.
What is involved? The patients will have been invited by one of the researchers, via a telephone call, and they will have sent the patient information for them to read.
Their appointments and schedule will remain the same in spite of participation. If they choose to take part and are randomly allocated to the MOOC group, a member of research team will issue them with details of how to access the course. Three to six weeks later the research team will contact them to test their recall over the phone of some important information about bariatric surgery. At six week's after the procedure, the research team will send a copy of the SDM Q9 (shared decision making Q9) questionnaire to complete and send back. This is a questionnaire that asks about satisfaction with the shared decision making process. If a patient is randomly allocated to the non MOOC group, they will also receive a recall test and a questionnaire after the consultant appointment in order to compare the two groups.
What is the purpose of the trial? The purpose of this study is to find out if using a patient information course on a massive open online course platform (MOOC) is useful to help the consent process by testing patient recall and also to test satisfaction with the shared decision making process compared to what current practice is.
Full description
The consenting process is not merely signing a form to allow an intervention or procedure to happen but is a process that allows the sharing of information regarding the procedure which concerns it's benefits, risks and alternatives.
Shared decision making can therefore be defined as a two way process that allows patients to express their preferences and opinions regarding pros, cons and alternatives to a particular procedure and allows the clinician to explain these pros, cons and alternatives on an individual basis. The Royal College of Surgeons has produced guidelines on shared decision making and consent, highlighting the paradigm shift that has occurred in the last ten years in this regard from what was traditionally a more paternalistic unidirectional approach. The College guidelines go further in recommending clinicians to encourage patients to seek web based and other information.
Despite this and the favourable view of both clinicians and patients towards shared decision making, it is clear that it is still in its infancy as highlighted in a 2018 systematic review by de Mik et al. This systematic review of thirty two studies highlights a need for further research with regards to interventions to improve shared decision making. Moreover, reviews from the NHS litigation authority claims against 11 surgical specialties over a ten year period revealed that failure to adequately consent was one of the three leading causes of claim with an estimated £1.5 billion paid out to claimants from 2004 to 2014. It is in the clinician's and patient's benefit for the decision making process to be robust and adequate. It is clear the shared decision making process needs to evolve in practice and where researchers of this study feel Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) can play a role.
Massive Open Online Courses have existed as a disruptor in the education sector and allow short courses to a large unrestricted and undifferentiated number of students, on a flexible basis on a wide variety of subjects. Courses are considered more democratic and accessible than traditional higher education courses as they are more inclusive, largely have no pre-requisites and usually free of charge from a range of higher education institutions. MOOCs can also reduce the need for human capital, allow for templates for creation of further courses/patient decision aids and reduce costs of information dissemination. They are also more sustainable and interactive than traditional patient leaflets, can be updated easily and usually involve small tests and certificates as proof of completion as well as being more environmentally friendly.
Thus the trial aims to cover two main unexplored concepts. The first is the feasibility of engaging patients and clinicians in MOOC creation for bariatric surgery. The second is trialing the MOOC in terms of utility as a patient decision aid versus traditional methods of patient information dissemination, which in the researcher's case is a patient leaflet and traditional consenting process. Utility would be investigated by means of ability to recall information and also patient satisfaction with the process using a validated questionnaire.
Enrollment
Sex
Ages
Volunteers
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Primary purpose
Allocation
Interventional model
Masking
80 participants in 2 patient groups
Loading...
Central trial contact
Aya Musbahi, MBCHB MBA FRCS
Data sourced from clinicaltrials.gov
Clinical trials
Research sites
Resources
Legal