Music Therapy's Impact on University Students' Social and Mental Health

The University of Hong Kong (HKU)

Status: Enrolling

Conditions: Depressive Symptoms; Anxiety; Stress

Treatments: Behavioral: Music Therapy Songwriting Intervention

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT07024979

EA240556

Details and patient eligibility

About

In recent years, university education has become more challenging due to increased academic competition. A rising number of university students globally are currently being diagnosed with mental health problems, and previous research suggests that insufficient social support plays a significant role in the development of mental illnesses, such as symptoms of depression and anxiety. Music Therapy has been widely used in emotional regulation, offering a promising solution for people struggling with anxiety, depression, and social isolation. Research on the neural mechanisms underlying music therapy represents rapidly growing field of study. Hyperscanning is one of the useful neuroscience study methods, which is widely-used for study interbrain synchronization, refers to the simultaneous measurement of brain activity in two or more individuals who are interacting with each other. This study aims to investigate the effectiveness of music therapy intervention in enhancing mental health and social skills of university students with depressed, anxious, and stress symptoms. This current study will adopt a 2-arm randomized controlled design comparing therapeutic songwriting (experimental condition) with non-therapeutic music listening and discussion (control condition). Upon screening for inclusion criteria, baseline data will be collected; and eligible participants will be randomized into either 4 individual music therapy sessions or non-therapeutic music listening and discussion sessions.

Full description

A rising number of university students globally are currently being diagnosed with mental health problems, and previous research suggests that insufficient social support plays a significant role in the development of mental illnesses, such as symptoms of depression and stress. Recent research indicates that 2.6% of young people worldwide experience depression, which is often associated with insufficient social interactions, challenges in emotional regulation, and unhealthy social relationships. These challenges may further impact their educational attainment, mental well-being, and quality of life. To address the impairment of mental health problems and its related influence on youths and their families, researchers, psychiatrists, and clinical therapists have been exploring innovative treatment approaches. Music therapy is one of these approaches.

In recent years, researchers have shifted their focus from simply demonstrating the effectiveness of music therapy treatment toward a deeper exploration of the underlying mechanisms of music used in these interventions. The field of research on Interbrain Synchronization (IBS) offers valuable insights into the intricate neural activities occurring across different brains and brain regions during human interaction. Hyperscanning, a widely-used method for studying interbrain synchronization, refers to the simultaneous measurement of brain activity in two or more individuals who are interacting with each other through various techniques, such as functional magnetic response imaging (fMRI), electroencephalography (EEG), magnetoencephalography (MEG), and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS). The use of hyperscaning methods during clinical music therapy sessions may provide the opportunity to understand how music interventions affect the neural connections between therapist and client during a real clinical environment. However, a limited number of studies specifically examine this phenomenon within the unique setting of music therapy.

This study aims to bridge the gap between neuroscience, clinical music therapy, social relationships, and mental health by investigating the effects of EEG interbrain synchronization in undergraduate students. It seeks to explore further the connections between music, the brain, and psychological well-being, aiming to understand the underlying neurological mechanism.

This current study will adopt a 2-arm randomized controlled design comparing therapeutic songwriting (experimental condition) with non-therapeutic music listening and discussion (control condition). To address the research objectives, this study will track psychological and neurophysiological changes across four individual sessions through a combination of repeated measures. Participants and music therapists will wear synchronized EEG caps during each session to capture interbrain dynamics, while participants complete post-session therapeutic relationship and satisfaction ratings. Mental health outcomes will be assessed using standardized questionnaires administered at baseline (pre-intervention) and immediately following the final session (post-intervention). This multi-method approach integrates: 1) temporal tracking of psychological changes (both immediate session-level effects and cumulative intervention effects), 2) objective neurophysiological data on therapeutic rapport, and 3) subjective evaluations of the therapeutic process, collectively provide a multidimensional understanding of music therapy mechanisms.

Enrollment: 20 estimated patients

Sex: Female

Ages: 18 to 35 years old

Volunteers: Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• (1) adults who aged between 18-40
• (2) without any mental diagnosis
• (3) able to speak and read Mandarin, Cantonese, or English
• (4) moderate stress or problems in academic activities, problems in interpersonal relationships, or adaptability to college life.
• (5) participants DASS-21 score >= "Moderate" severity on each subscale (Depression >= 14; Anxiety >= 10; Stress >= 19).

Exclusion criteria

• (1) has more than 10 consecutive years professional music training
• (2) with chronic illness and taking medication
• (3) with prior history of brain trauma or brain surgery
• (4) wearing metal piercings or implants.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Double Blind

---

20 participants in 2 patient groups

Music Therapy Songwriting Intervention

Experimental group

Description:

This arm of participants will be receiving individual music therapy songwriting intervention as intervention.

Treatment:

Behavioral: Music Therapy Songwriting Intervention

Non-therapeutic Music Listening and Discussion

No Intervention group

Description:

This arm of participants will receive non-therapeutic music listening and discussion (non-therapeutic topics/techniques) sessions as the control condition. This active control condition matches the experimental intervention in format and include musical element, but excludes therapeutic components. The music therapist will ask the participant to provide 3 to 4 their preferred songs. Then they will listen to these songs through standardized equipment. Following each song, the therapist facilitates a structured discussion focused on normal domains and non-therapeutic topics, such as music styles, tempos, and factual information about artists and genres.