Outcomes Following Severe Distal Tibia, Ankle and/or Foot Trauma: Comparison of Limb Salvage Versus Transtibial Amputation Protocol (OUTLET)

Major Extremity Trauma Research Consortium

Status: Completed

Conditions: Major Bone Articular Surface Loss; Severe Ankle Injury; Severe Distal Tibia Injury; Major Soft Tissue Loss; Major Ankle Articular Surface Loss; Severe Foot Injury

Study type: Observational

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT01606501

W81XWH-09-2-0108-OUT

Details and patient eligibility

About

The primary aim this prospective longitudinal observational outcomes study is to compare 18 month functional outcomes and health related quality of life (HRQoL) of patients undergoing salvage versus amputation following severe distal tibia, ankle and/or foot fractures with major soft tissue, bone and/or ankle articular surface loss. Functional outcomes and HRQoL will be measured using well established self reported measures, including the Veterans Rand Health Survey (VR-12) and the Short Musculoskeletal Functional Assessment (SMFA).

Hypothesis 1: As a group, salvage patients with severe distal tibia, ankle and/or foot injuries with major soft tissue, bone and/or ankle articular surface loss will have similar functional outcomes and HRQoL had they undergone a transtibial amputation (within 6 weeks of injury).

Hypothesis 2: The subgroup of salvage patients who have either (1) a soft tissue injury that requires tissue transfer; (2) articular damage requiring arthrodesis of the ankle joint; or (3) bone loss at the distal tibia or ankle will have better functional outcomes and HRQoL had they undergone a transtibial amputation (within 6 weeks of injury).

Enrollment: 664 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18 to 60 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Patients with an injury that meets at least one of the following:

   1. Gustilo type III pilon fractures consistent with one of the following OTA codes: 43B1.3, 43B2-B3, 43C, 44B, 44C
   2. Gustilo type III B or C ankle fractures
   3. Gustilo type III mid and/or hind foot fractures consistent with one of the following OTA codes: 81B2-B3, 82B and 82C
   4. Open foot crush or blast injuries from high energy mechanism involving the mid and /or hind foot with significant soft tissues damage
   5. Other severe foot injury (including closed foot crush or blast injuries)

2. Ages 18-60 inclusive.

3. Admitted to the hospital prior to definitive wound closure.

Inclusion notes:

1. Patients may have other injuries except as noted below under exclusion criteria.

2. Foot crush and blast injuries are eligible if they are considered to be at significant risk for impaired outcome with moderate to severe disability and typically include one of the following associated injuries:

   1. ankle dislocation (80A)
   2. subtalar dislocation (80B)
   3. extruded talus
   4. chopart dislocation (80C)
   5. multiple midfoot dislocations (80C)
   6. three or greater proximal metatarsal fractures
   7. heel pad/plantar degloving
   8. extensive muscle necrosis in an open injury from crush, ischemia and/or foot compartment syndrome

3. These injuries may include "toe-pan" injuries from motor vehicle accidents and crush-like injuries from motorcycle accidents, and traumatic amputations.

Exclusion criteria

1. Patient has a Glasgow Coma Scale motor score of 0-4 or a Glasgow Coma Scale motor score of 5 with a significant traumatic brain injury (defined as an AIS code of 5 or 6) at time of consent

2. Patient has third degree burns on >10% total surface area affecting the study limb

3. Patient has a previous leg or foot amputation of either limb

4. Patient is non-ambulatory due to an associated complete spinal cord injury

5. Patient non-ambulatory pre-injury

6. Patient speaks neither English nor Spanish

7. Patient likely to have severe problems with maintaining follow- up due to at least one of the following:

   1. Patient has been diagnosed with a severe psychiatric condition
   2. Patient is intellectually challenged without adequate family support
   3. Patient lives outside the hospital's catchment area
   4. Follow-up is planned at another medical center
   5. Patients who are prisoners or homeless

Trial design

664 participants in 2 patient groups

Limb Salvage patients

Description:

Patients undergoing limb salvage following severe distal tibia, ankle and/or foot injuries with major soft tissue, bone and/or ankle articular surface loss.

Transtibial Amputation patients

Description:

Patients undergoing transtibial amputation following severe distal tibia, ankle and/or foot injuries with major soft tissue, bone and/or ankle articular surface loss.