Reconstruction of Orbital Floor Blow-out Fractures by Titanium Mesh Versus Autogenous Iliac Graft

Assiut University

Status: Completed

Conditions: Blow-Out Fractures

Treatments: Procedure: autogenous iliac graft; Procedure: Titanium mesh

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT07340879

04-2023-300338

Details and patient eligibility

About

Blow-out fractures result from direct blunt impacts to the orbit which causes an immediate rise increase in intra-orbital pressure. Decompression via fracture of the orbital floor then occurs. Motor vehicle accidents are the main cause of orbital trauma. Also, industrial accidents, sports-related facial trauma, and assaults are important causes.

Clinical manifestations include ecchymosis, limitation of eye movements resulting in diplopia, enophthalmos. Very rarely, severe pain and nausea immediately after the injury are reported.

Radiologic evaluation including computed tomography (CT), plane radiology and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are the mainstay diagnostic modalities used for evaluation of cases with orbital trauma.

Treatment of the orbital blow-out fractures is aimed at restoring floor continuity, thus providing adequate support for orbital contents preventing their herniation and incarceration, thereby possible subsequent fibrosis of soft tissues most importantly extraocular muscles.

Various alloplastic or autogenous grafts are used for reconstruction of orbital blow-out fractures.

Full description

A prospective interventional randomized controlled study, including 80 patients (who presented at trauma unit in Assiut university hospital between May 2020 to May 2023 and fulfilled the inclusion criteria) was conducted. Patients with orbital floor blow-out fractures were selected irrespective of their age and gender. The study followed the tenets of the Helsinki declaration and guidelines of the local research committee. An informed written consent was signed by all the patients who agreed to be enrolled in the study, or their relatives if consciously disturbed patients. All operations were done within 2 weeks of the trauma.

Patients were divided into 2 groups:

• Group I (40 patients) consists of immediate surgical reconstruction of pure orbital floor blow-out fractures by titanium mesh.
• Group II (40 patients) consists of immediate surgical reconstruction of pure orbital floor blow-out fractures by autogenous iliac graft.

Inclusion criteria:

Clinical Enophthalmos, diplopia, and/or limited ocular motility in one or more directions.

Radiological:

- CT scan (axial, coronal & 3 dimensional):

Fracture of the orbital floor with herniation of the orbital contents (extra-ocular muscles, or orbital fat).Exclusion criteria:

patients with bilateral orbital fractures or severe facial fractures. Also, patients with bad general condition or uncontrolled diabetes mellitus were excluded.

Ophthalmological examination of study subjects was performed by an expert ophthalmologist (MGA). This included examination of the anterior segment and evaluation of pupillary reflexes by penlight and slit lamp to document associated eye globe injuries. Fundus examination was carried out using binocular indirect ophthalmoscope. Also, measurement of the corrected distance visual acuity (CDVA) expressed as decimal notation using a chart projector utilizing built in Snellen's charts. Also, ocular motility examination in the six cardinal positions of eye movements was carried out to document any limitation of eye movement (direction and degree). Moreover, Hertel's exophthalmometer was used to measure the degree of enophthalmos in the involved eye. A difference of 2 or more millimeters between both eyes was considered significant for enophthalmos in the sunken eye. Ophthalmological features of study subjects. Postoperative care

• A head-up position was adopted by patients in the early postoperative period with application of cold compresses in order to reduce postoperative edema.
• Analgesia and antibiotics were prescribed.

Follow up:

Follow-up examinations to assess visual acuity, extra-ocular motility, pupillary reaction. Also, the degree of enophthalmos was measured. Assessment of sensation over the check to assess the degree of neuralgia and patients were asked about improvement in double vision. Those parameters were monitored for at least 6 months after surgery and up to one year.

Follow up orbital CT scan (coronal view was done for all patients in the study.

Enrollment: 80 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 20 to 60 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Clinical Enophthalmos, diplopia, and/or limited ocular motility in one or more directions.

Radiological:

- CT scan (axial, coronal & 3 dimensional): Fracture of the orbital floor with herniation of the orbital contents (extra-ocular muscles, or orbital fat)

Exclusion criteria

• patients with bilateral orbital fractures or severe facial fractures.
• Patients with bad general condition or uncontrolled diabetes mellitus.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

80 participants in 2 patient groups

Patients with orbital blow-out fractures

Active Comparator group

Description:

Treated by immediate surgical reconstruction of orbital floor blow-out fractures by titanium mesh (within 2 week of the trauma)

Treatment:

Procedure: Titanium mesh

Patients with orbital blow-out fractures were selected irrespective of their age and gender

Active Comparator group

Description:

Treated by immediate reconstruction of orbital floor by autogenous iliac graft (within 2 week of the trauma)

Treatment:

Procedure: autogenous iliac graft