Status and phase
Conditions
Treatments
About
In 2017, the World Health Organization (WHO) labeled scabies as a neglected tropical disease. It is a serious health problem especially in poor developing countries like Syria, where overcrowding, poverty, and war consequences are considered major factors for spreading the disease. Permethrin lotion or cream is the treatment of choice for scabies, and it is applied once a week for two consecutive weeks according to the global guidelines. However, most practitioners in Syria do not adhere to this standard regimen, and a variety of regimens are used instead based mostly on clinical experience. In this study, the investigators are comparing four different regimens of permethrin application and comparing Sulfur to permethrin in terms of efficacy and safety.
Full description
Background:
In 2017, the World Health Organization (WHO) labeled scabies as a neglected tropical disease that affects more than 200 million people at any time. Treating scabies in developing countries constitutes a major challenge because of factors like poverty, overcrowded areas, inadequate disease education, and low adherence to proper therapy, which together can contribute to treatment failure and the spread of the disease.
These factors abundantly exist in Syria as it is considered a developing, low-income country. Moreover, the long-term Syrian war added a significant negative impact to the socio-economic status and prevalence of scabies, raising the difficulty in controlling the disease.
Several treatment options may be used for classic scabies including permethrin 5%, crotamiton 10%, sulfur (5-10%) ointment, lindane 1%, and ivermectin. There is no ideal scabicide because the treatment choice changes according to the patient's situation, and any one of the previous agents may be used alone or in combination.
Permethrin 5% lotion or cream is the treatment of choice for scabies based on a 2007 updated Cochrane review. Most of the treatment guidelines in developing countries recommend applying the drug once a week for 8-14 hours and repeating the application after seven days. According to what is published in the medical literature, this regimen of permethrin application is usually effective and sufficient without significant drug resistance yet.
Sulfur is an old preparation for scabies treatment. It is usually used as a (5-10%) precipitated ointment over the whole body for two or three consecutive nights.
Unlike most scabicides, sulfur is effective in killing both the mites and the eggs. However, it is malodorous, cloth-spotting, and can cause irritant dermatitis. Despite the little clear scientific evidence on the clinical efficacy of sulfur and the low adherence to this treatment because of its unpleasant application effects, it is still used when the patient cannot tolerate other agents. Moreover, it is considered a safe choice in treating pregnant women and children, and it can be the only feasible scabicide in poor resources communities.
Although the evidence on repeated treatment (i.e., timing and frequency) is lacking, the majority of Syrian dermatology practitioners do not follow the classical regimen in prescribing permethrin with no specific and clear fact-based explanation of this variation. Based on a nationwide survey study the investigators conducted, 66% (105/159) of the Syrian dermatology practitioners tend to use more aggressive regimens in prescribing permethrin instead of the classic one-per-week recommended regimen.
The objective of the study:
To compare the efficacy of different regimens of permethrin application (i.e., varying in timing and frequency) to sulfur as a low-cost alternative. A secondary aim is to evaluate the adverse events and adherence.
Methods:
Participants and interventions It is a prospective, multi-center, randomized controlled trial that will be conducted at the dermatology departments of three academic hospitals run by the ministry of higher education in Syria; These hospitals are located in Damascus, Aleppo, and Latakia.
Diagnosis of scabies will be established based on the criteria of the International Alliance for the Control of Scabies (IACS 2020), which has three levels of certainty for diagnosing scabies; confirmed, clinical, and suspected scabies (Appendix A). Patients who fulfill the clinical or confirmed scabies items will be recruited. The investigators will examine the patient's skin looking for burrows, small papules, and vesicles which are the primary lesions of scabies, or the secondary lesions resulting from scratching and rubbing.
The severity of pruritus will be determined using the Verbal Rating Scale from zero (no itch) to four (very severe itch) (Appendix B). On the other hand, the severity of scabies will be measured by counting the number of lesions and grading the results as follows: score 0= Free of lesions (no scabies), score 1= 10 or fewer lesions (mild), score 2= 11- 49 lesions (moderate), score 3= 50 or more lesions (severe) (Appendix C).
Interventions:
All the participants will apply the medication in the same manner; the differences will be in the frequency of applications and showers between them. Directions of use for permethrin solution and sulfur ointment will be orally explained by the investigators to all participants with the help of figures specially designed for our study. The application of the solution will be to the whole body below the neck, including soles, between fingers and toe creases, in the folds of wrist and waistline, armpits, preauricular area, on the genitals, and beneath fingernails and toenails. Nails will be cut short, and sex will be avoided during treatment. If the patient is a child, hands and feet should be rubbed well. No supplementary treatment other than the prescribed anti-scapetic treatment is allowed during the study. Hygiene instructions are advised to be strictly followed to avoid recurrence and failure of treatment. Treatment was also instructed to all family members at the same time, including washing clothes and bedsheets at 60-celsius degrees. Clothes that cannot be washed will be put in a black plastic bag for 3 days, and vacuum cleaning will be instructed for house furniture.
The five arms of the study represent four different regimens of permethrin 5% solution application and a sulfur ointment group. The first arm (P1) will serve as the control group (i.e., active comparator), which is the standard regimen of permethrin application according to global guidelines (7). Patients on this arm will apply the 5% permethrin solution on day one, rinse it after eight hours and reapply it on day eight. Patients in group two (Arm P2) will apply the same solution on days one, two, and three then rinse it (without rinsing in between these days) and reapply it on days eight, nine, and ten then rinse it similarly to the first round. Participants in group three (Arm P3) will apply the solution on days one, two, and three then rinse it (without rinsing in between these days) and reapply it on day eight then rinse it. Participants in group four (Arm P4) will apply the solution on day one then rinse it, and on day two then rinse it. Later on day eight, they will re-apply the solution again and rinse it. Participants in group five (Arm S) will apply the ointment for three consecutive days without rinsing in between these days. Each application of the solution or the ointment is left for at least 8 hours (see figure 1 in Appendix D). Enough amounts of the previous antiscabetic medications will be distributed for free to all participants to ensure adherence and adequate and proper use of medication.
Participants who have a secondary infection will be treated with azithromycin capsules 500 mg for three consecutive days.
Participant timeline:
Participants will be assessed biweekly for at least 4 weeks starting with the day of the first application of the treatment. Participants who recovered at the "first visit" two weeks after applying the treatment will be re-evaluated at the "second visit" during the fourth week to check for recurrence. Participants who did not recover at the first visit will reapply the treatment of permethrin (according to their group regimen) as for the permethrin groups or reapply the sulfur (Arm S) as for the sulfur group. Then they will be re-evaluated at the "second visit" (week 4) and again at an additional "third visit" during week 6.
Patients who do not respond to the repeated treatment or experience recurrence (i.e., the reappearance of new lesions after complete recovery) will be treated with benzyl benzoate lotion as an alternative treatment (see figure 2 in Appendix D)
Assignment of interventions Participants will be randomly assigned to the five arms of the study using a web-based random number generator (randomlists.com). Investigators in each center will allocate the participants to the proper group and give the instructions and medications to them.
No blinding will be applied due to the different regimens of applying the medication in the permethrin groups and the different pharmaceutical properties of permethrin and sulfur.
Data collection, management, and analysis
Data collection methods:
After confirming the diagnosis according to the diagnosis criteria, data will be collected by the investigators directly from the participants, In addition to the demographic data, the structured questionnaire includes the history of the complaint, presence of secondary infection, number of family members, and the severity of itching. The follow-up questionnaire is more concise and it assesses treatment outcomes and the compliance of patients and their contacts to the instructions, in addition to the assessment of the medication side effects.
Collected data will be written on a paper form then entered into an electronic form, which will be reviewed and double-checked by the principal investigator. Photos will be taken using a mobile camera before treatment and on each visit to allow visual comparison.
Statistical methods:
Counts and percentages will be used for nominal variables. Medians and interquartile ranges will represent the continuous variables. Chi-square test will be used to study the association between categorical variables and Kruskal Wallis for continuous data. The analysis will be done using SPSS 25 software primarily, along with figures illustrated using Microsoft EXCEL.
APPENDIX A: International Alliance for the Control of Scabies (IACS 2020) A.confirmed scabies
At least one of:
A1: Mites, eggs, or faeces on light microscopy of skin samples A2: Mites, eggs, or faeces visualized on an individual using a high-powered imaging device A3: Mite visualized on an individual using dermoscopy
B. Clinical scabies
At least one of:
B1: Scabies burrows B2: Typical lesions affecting male genitalia B3: Typical lesions in a typical distribution and two history features H1: Itch H2: Positive contact history
C. Suspected scabies
One of:
C1: Typical lesions in a typical distribution and one history feature C2: Atypical lesions or atypical distribution and two history features History features
APPENDIX B: Verbal rating scale of pruritus 0 = No itch
APPENDIX C: Rating the lesions count Score 0 = no scabies Score 1 = lesions are 10 or less /mild/ Score 2 = lesions are between 11 - 49 /moderate/ Score 3 = lesions are 50 or more /severe/
Enrollment
Sex
Ages
Volunteers
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Primary purpose
Allocation
Interventional model
Masking
250 participants in 5 patient groups
Loading...
Data sourced from clinicaltrials.gov
Clinical trials
Research sites
Resources
Legal