TaTME Versus Open Intersphincteric Resection After Neoadjuvant Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy.

Osama Mohammad Ali ElDamshety

Status: Completed

Conditions: Rectal Cancer

Treatments: Device: transanal minimally invasive intersphincteric resection; Procedure: Open intersphincteric resection

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT01836926

Mansoura oncology centre

Details and patient eligibility

About

The two surgical options for lower 1/3 rectal cancer is APR and sphincter sparing procedures. Intersphincteric resection is procedure to treat very low rectal cancer within 2 cm from the dentate line to avoid permanent colostomy,improves the quality of life with better genitourinary function. Neoadjuvant chemo-radiotherapy is routine for T3 cases.

Full description

During the period between April 2013 and July 2019, a non-randomized controlled study was performed at two tertiary centers; Oncology Centre of Mansoura University and Policlinico Umberto Primo surgery department of SAPIENZA university of Rome after referral from the clinical oncology and nuclear medicine department. After diagnosis of ultralow rectal cancer, a written informed consent was obtained from patients after full explanation of the procedure, the likely outcome and the potential complications that may occur. Digital rectal examination was conducted to assess the distance of lower tumor margin from the anal verge and the anal tone. Anesthetic fitness and tumour markers (CEA) were assessed. Pelvis MRI and/or endorectal ultrasound (EUS), abdomen and chest CT scan and colonoscopy with biopsy were done for all cases. Re-evaluation after neoadjuvant chemo-radiotherapy by MRI and EUS. Inclusion criteria included a very low rectal cancer below 5 cm from the anal verge with normally continent and tumor-free external anal sphincter. Neoadjuvant treatment was given to all patients with T3 or node positive tumors. Exclusion criteria were T4, metastatic tumors and fecal incontinence. Fifty patients were excluded from the study (Fig.1). One hundred and ten patients with ultralow rectal adenocarcinoma, with matched age and sex (table 1), were non-randomly classified into two equal groups: the control group included 55 patents that underwent sphincter sparing by open ISR with TME (O-ISR Group) and the 2nd group included 55 patents that underwent Transanal minimally invasive ISR with TME (TAMIS Group).

Surgical technique:

In open ISR, the inferior mesenteric vessels were highly ligated. After full mobilization of the left colon and splenic flexure was done, the plane for TME was followed down in the pelvis superficial to the hypogastric fascia as low as possible to enter into the posterior intersphincteric plane. A non-endoscopic perineal phase was then initiated using an anal lone-star retractor to expose the anal canal. Both the mucosa and the muscular layer were incised 1cm below the tumor margin to transect the internal anal sphincter (IAS) and then closed by purse string sutures. The dissection continued between IAS and the external anal sphincter (EAS) starting posteriorly then laterally, where EAS is easier to identify, then anteriorly where the plane presented more adhesions with the urethra in male or vagina in female till reaching the abdominal dissection. Proximal division of the specimen started just below the site of inferior mesenteric vessels ligation and continued till division of the marginal artery at the site of the required anastomosis. The Specimen extraction and division was done extra-anal. A defunctioning ileostomy was done in all cases.

In TAMIS-TME, using a lone star retractor, the 1st step was to divide and close the anal canal by purse-string suturing to enter the intersphincteric plane. Using TEo platform (Karl Storz, Tuttilingen, Germany) (fig. 2) with a 4 cm size operating proctoscope diameter, Transanal endoscopic dissection was initiated and continued in the intersphincteric plane starting posteriorly then laterally. Partial or high ISR started at the dentate line to remove the upper half of IAS for ultralow tumors at 3 to 4.5 from anal verge. Total or low ISR started 1 cm below the dentate line, removing the whole of IAS for tumours below 3 cm from the anal verge. The endoscopic dissection continued in the same sequence as the control group along the levator ani. Then continue posteriorly till reaching as much as possible, then dissection continued laterally and anteriorly to reach the peritoneal reflection. Then, the laparoscopic phase was initiated to ligate the inferior mesenteric vessels and mobilize the splenic flexure and left colon. The peritoneal reflections were then divided to connect to the transanal part. The specimen was then extracted transanally and the Colo-anal anastomosis was done in two layers. A defunctioning ileostomy was done in all cases.

Enrollment: 110 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18 to 80 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Patients with low rectal carcinoma(The lowest margin of tumor located 3 cm from anal verge ; ≤ 2 cm from dentate lines; 1 cm from anorectal rings.
• Local spread restricted to the rectal wall or the internal anal sphincter.
• Adequate preoperative sphincter function and continence.
• Absence of distant metastasis.

Exclusion criteria

• Contraindications to major surgery and American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Physical Status scoring 4.
• Metastatic rectal cancer.
• Those in Dukes stage D (T4 lesion).
• Undifferentiated tumours.
• Local infiltration of external anal sphincter or levator ani muscles.
• Tumor located more than 2 cm above the dentate line.
• Presence of fecal incontinence.
• Patients unwilling to take part in the study.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Non-Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

110 participants in 2 patient groups

Open intersphincteric resection

Active Comparator group

Description:

surgical Instruments for open approach intervention: Open laparotomy through abdominal incision and mobilization of the colon and rectum up to the splenic flexure with high ligation of the inferior mesenteric vessels and mesorectal excision till the levator ani then the peranal approach to resect the distal margin of the rectum through high or low intersphincteric resection in the plane between internal and external anal sphincters.

Treatment:

Procedure: Open intersphincteric resection

laparoscopic intersphincteric resection .

Active Comparator group

Description:

instruments used: 4 or 5 laparoscopic trocars (two or three (10-mm) trocar, Two 5-mm trocars and a 12-mm trocar with reducers),Three 5-mm fenestrated grasping forceps, Five-millimetre coagulating shears, a 5-mm straight grasping forceps, Harmonic scalpel, 5 or 10 mm, a 10-mm fenestrated forceps, a 10-mm dissector,5 mm Bipolar grasper, a 5-mm needle holder, Twelve-millimetre linear staplers intervention: 1. Trocar Placement and Exposure 2. Rectosigmoid Mobilization and Control of Inferior Mesenteric Vessels 3. Taking Down the Splenic Flexure 4. rectal dissection till the levator ani muscle and resection of thye lateral ligaments then the peranal phase as in the laparotomy approach.

Treatment:

Device: transanal minimally invasive intersphincteric resection