The Effects of Estrogen Withdrawal on Mood Symptoms in Women

National Institutes of Health (NIH)

Status: Completed

Conditions: Healthy; Perimenopausal Depression; Depression; Post Menopausal

Study type: Observational

Funder types: NIH

Identifiers

NCT00060736

030175

03-M-0175

Details and patient eligibility

About

This study evaluates the effects on mood when stopping estrogen replacement therapy.

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effects of estrogen levels on perimenopausal depression. This study will examine short-term withdrawal of estrogen in women whose mood had improved with estrogen therapy.

Perimenopause-related mood disorders cause significant distress in a large number of women. Evidence suggests that estradiol may have beneficial effects in women with perimenopausal depression. However, the effect of declining estradiol secretion during perimenopause has not been fully examined.

Peri- and post-menopausal women who experience a remission of perimenopause-related depression symptoms while on estrogen therapy and a control group of healthy volunteers on hormone replacement therapy (HRT) will be switched from their current form of HRT to estradiol for a 3-week period; volunteers will also complete symptom ratings to confirm the absence of mood symptoms. Participants will then be randomly assigned to either continue estradiol or take a placebo (an inactive pill) for an additional 3 weeks. Mood ratings will be used to determine response to estradiol withdrawal.

...

Full description

Perimenopause-related mood disorders cause significant distress to a large number of women. Recent studies have reported the therapeutic benefits of estradiol in women with these mood disorders; however, a relevant pathophysiologic role of declining estradiol secretion during the perimenopause has not been demonstrated. In this protocol we wish to investigate the effects of acute withdrawal of estradiol on mood under placebo controlled conditions. Thus, mood and behavior symptoms may be precipitated by the experimental conditions of this protocol. This protocol will address the following hypothesis: women with a past history of perimenopause-related depression but not women without such a history will experience a recurrence of mood and behavioral symptoms during acute estradiol withdrawal but not during continued estradiol administration. The nature of the relationship between the declining secretion of estradiol and mood in perimenopausal depressed women will be examined as follows: Peri- and postmenopausal women reporting the onset of depression during the perimenopause and who report remission of depressive symptoms on estrogen therapy (ET) will be withdrawn from ET under blinded and placebo-controlled conditions. We will recruit as a comparison group asymptomatic women on hormone replacement and without a history of perimenopause-related depression. During a three week baseline phase, all women will be switched from their current form of hormone replacement therapy to estradiol and will complete symptom ratings to confirm the absence of mood symptoms prior to entry into the study. After the screening, all women will be randomized to receive either estradiol or placebo for an additional three weeks. Comparison of mood ratings during these contrasting treatment conditions will allow us to examine the specific role of estrogen withdrawal in depression that is responsive to ET.

Enrollment: 60 patients

Sex: Female

Ages: 45 to 65 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

• INCLUSION CRITERIA:

All subjects for this protocol will be either self-referred in response to newspaper advertisements or referred by their personal physician. The women participating in this protocol will have previously completed the screening protocol # 88-M-0131 and, therefore, will have had the presence or absence of perimenopausal or menopausal reproductive status evaluated and documented.

1. Women with a past perimenopause-related depression (within 12 years) and whose depression responded to ET will be recruited to participate in this randomized, parallel-design, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Women with histories of either perimenopausal depression that was not responsive to ET or hormone replacement therapy-induced dysphoria due to either the estrogen or the progesterone components of their hormone replacement will be excluded. The diagnosis of perimenopause-related depression will be based on a history of a past depressive episode (major or minor depression confirmed by Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (SCID) or Schedule of Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia-Lifetime Version (SADS-L), respectively) at midlife in association with menstrual cycle irregularity and the history of remission (also confirmed by SCID or SADS-L) of this depression after ET. Additionally, all women will report that they were placed on HRT for the treatment of perimenopausal symptoms, including depression.
2. Age 45 to 65
3. In good medical health

<TAB>

Women without past perimenopausal depression -

To control for the effects of the hormonal manipulations in this protocol, we will also recruit a group of asymptomatic controls who are either currently on ET or were prescribed ET previously and with no previous history of perimenopause-related depression or HRT-induced dysphoria. Women who participate in this study as the asymptomatic comparison group will meet the following criteria:

1. Women who received hormone therapy (HT) with no previous history of perimenopause-related depression or HT-induced dysphoria
2. No current mood or behavioral problems
3. Age 45 to 65
4. In good medical health

EXCLUSION CRITERIA:

1. past history of severe major depression with suicidal ideation
2. current treatment with antidepressant medications
3. history of ischemic cardiac disease, pulmonary embolism, or thrombophlebitis
4. renal disease
5. hepatic dysfunction
6. women with a history of carcinoma of the breast
7. women with a history of uterine cancer, ill-defined pelvic lesions, particularly undiagnosed ovarian enlargement, undiagnosed vaginal bleeding
8. pregnant women
9. cerebrovascular disease (stroke)
10. recurrent migraine headaches