The Impact of 3D-CBCT Imaging on Nerve Injuries During Wisdom Tooth Surgery (IMPACTION)

University of Aberdeen

Status: Enrolling

Conditions: Impacted Third Molar Tooth; Inferior Alveolar Nerve Injuries

Treatments: Radiation: 2D-OPG; Radiation: 3D-CBCT

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT06261853

2-081-23

Details and patient eligibility

About

The investigators aim to investigate if the additional information available from a 3D scan of the wisdom tooth can reduce the risk of nerve injury during wisdom tooth surgery compared to conventional 2D images.

Wisdom tooth surgery is a common surgical procedures that a significant proportion of the population will undergo. As with any other surgical procedure, there are potential complications, of which, injury to the nerve supplying feeling to the lip, chin, and tongue is the most significant. This can lead to persistent pain, tingling, or numbness that may impact a patient's ability to eat and function.

The risk of nerve injury during wisdom tooth surgery is assessed using X-ray images, which show the position of the nerve and tooth in the jawbone. 2D and 3D scans are used, which have their own advantages and disadvantages such as reduced cost and radiation dose with 2D or more information from 3D images, but it remains unclear which is better at reducing the risk of nerve injuries.

Full description

This pragmatic clinical trial is a multi-centre, two-arm, single-blind randomised controlled trial.

The primary research question is:

1. Does the additional information provided by a 3D scan, over a 2D x-ray, reduce the number of nerve injuries occurring during wisdom tooth surgery.

The secondary objectives are:

1. Does the additional information provided by the 3D scan, over the 2D x-ray, reduce the operation time?
2. Does the additional information provided by the 3D scan, over the 2D x-ray, impact the number and type of complications occuring during wisdom tooth surgery?
3. Does the additional information provided by the 3D scan, over the 2D x-ray, impact the number and type of complications observed after wisdom tooth surgery?

The study intervention:

1. On the day of surgery, the surgeon will utilise only one imaging technique, either the 2D OPG or the 3D CBCT, during wisdom tooth surgery. The trial arm allocation will be noted on their operating list alongside the planned procedure details. Conventionally, surgeons would have access to both images and therefore, it is difficult to determine the relative impact of each on surgical outcomes. The patient should observe no difference in their care in either arm of the trial on the day of surgery as they wouldn't typically be aware of which image was being utilised.
2. Data will be collected peri-operatively by way of a proforma completed by the surgeon. If the surgeon feels the need to use the other imaging modality to which the patient is allocated, for example, to maintain standards of care, this will be recorded along with the reasons why. Operating time and intraoperative complications will also be documented for each surgical procedure.
3. One week after the surgery, participants will receive a follow-up phone call from a research team member, which should last no more than five minutes. They will be asked five 'yes/no' questions about their recovery. Typically, patients having wisdom tooth surgery are not routinely followed up after their surgery unless specifically requested by the surgeon, therefore, this could be seen as an improved level of care for most patients especially as the research team member will have access to the post-operative care instructions from the department and can ask a surgeon to contact the patient if requested or deemed necessary.
4. After the one-week postoperative telephone review, the participant will be discharged from the study even if they continue to receive post-operative care, as clinically indicated, from their surgeon. If the patient is subsequently listed for another wisdom tooth surgical procedure and still meets the inclusion criteria, they may be invited to enrol again in the study.

Enrollment: 1,292 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 16+ years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

1. Individuals are seen in the Oral Surgery department with a 2D-OPG x-ray and a diagnosis of a mandibular wisdom tooth that requires surgical treatment.
2. Individuals requiring a 3D-CBCT to further assess the relationship between the wisdom tooth and the inferior alveolar nerve.
3. Individuals who are to undergo surgical treatment for their wisdom tooth regardless of the surgical approach (e.g. coronectomy or extraction) or the anaesthetic technique utilised.
4. Individuals without any pre-existing neurological deficit of cranial nerve V (trigeminal nerve) or medical conditions or medications that may cause changes in neurosensory function.
5. Individuals over the age of 16 and willing and able to provide valid informed consent for themselves.
6. Individuals with adequate English comprehension to read the written PIS and consent form and understand the follow-up call questions.
7. Individuals willing to provide contact details to allow a telephone follow-up call one week after their surgery.

Exclusion criteria

1. Individuals who do not have the capacity to consent for themselves.
2. Individuals taking medicines or having medical conditions and disorders that impair neurosensory function.
3. Individuals requiring wisdom tooth surgery to manage associated pathology such as cysts, fractures, or tumours where the pathological condition may interfere with the neurosensory function of the trigeminal nerve at 1 week post-operatively.
4. Individuals who are unable to read or speak English.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Prevention

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Double Blind

---

1,292 participants in 2 patient groups

3D-CBCT Scan

Experimental group

Description:

The surgeons will only utilise the 3D-CBCT scan of their patient during wisdom tooth surgery. The patient should observe no difference in their care in this arm of the trial on the day of surgery as they wouldn't typically be aware of which image was being viewed

Treatment:

Radiation: 3D-CBCT

2D-OPG X-ray

Active Comparator group

Description:

The surgeons will only utilise the 2D-OPG X-ray of their patient during wisdom tooth surgery. The patient should observe no difference in their care in this arm of the trial on the day of surgery as they wouldn't typically be aware of which image was being viewed

Treatment:

Radiation: 2D-OPG