Thoracic Spine Thrust Manipulation for Cervicogenic Headaches: A Randomized Clinical Trial

University of Colorado Denver (CU Denver)

Status: Completed

Conditions: Headache Disorders, Secondary

Treatments: Procedure: Thoracic Manipulation (Control wait-list); Procedure: Thoracic manipulation (Manipulation Group)

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT02708953

15-0983

Details and patient eligibility

About

Headaches have been listed as 1 of the 10 most disabling conditions worldwide. (Stovner et al., 2007) and cervicogenic headaches (CeHs) comprise 15% of the individuals with these complaints. (Nillsson, 1995); (Fernandez de-las-penas et al., 2005) The current best approach to the conservative care of this condition has yet to be determined. The primary aim of this study is to determine whether individuals with CeHs will respond to a program of thoracic spine thrust manipulation in isolation. This may further the current body of evidence by offering an alternative, potentially safer approach to the conservative care of individuals with this condition. Additionally, results of this study may serve to drive a larger scale Randomized Clinical Trial (RCT) by offering information regarding feasibility of recruitment of individuals with chronic CeHs as well as timing and dosing of the intervention.

Full description

Headaches have been listed as 1 of the 10 most disabling conditions worldwide. (Stovner et al., 2007) and cervicogenic headaches (CeHs) comprise 15% of the individuals with these complaints. (Nillsson, 1995); (Fernandez de-las-penas et al., 2005) The current best approach to the conservative care of this condition has yet to be determined. Evidence suggests that manipulative therapy aimed at the cervical spine in combination with exercise is helpful in alleviating these symptoms. (Jull et al., 2002) The risk of injury from cervical spine manipulative techniques has been documented to be remote (Haldeman et al., 2002; DiFabio 1999), however the potential consequences can be severe. Therefore with inherently lower risks, thoracic spine manipulations may be a suitable alternative as the evidence is accumulating for its influence on the cervical spine. (Mintken et al., 2010; Boyles et al., 2009; Cleland et al., 2005 & 2007 A & B, 2010; Flynn et al., 2001; Fernandez-de-las-penas et al., 2004; Piva et al., 2000; Browder et al., 2004) The primary aim of this study is to determine whether individuals with CeHs will respond to a program of thoracic spine thrust manipulation in isolation. This may further the current body of evidence by offering an alternative, potentially safer approach to the conservative care of individuals with this condition. Additionally, results of this study may serve to drive a larger scale RCT by offering information regarding feasibility of recruitment of individuals with chronic CeHs as well as timing and dosing of the intervention.

Enrollment: 48 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18 to 60 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Between 18 and 60 years old Sjaastad et al for CeH, which included
• unilateral or unilateral dominant side-consistent headache associated with neck pain and aggravated by neck postures or movement (Sjaastad et al., 1998)
• joint tenderness in at least one of the three upper cervical joints (C0-C3) as assessed by manual palpation
• headache frequency of at least one per week over the past 2 months

Exclusion criteria

• red flags noted in the patient's Neck Medical Screening Questionnaire (e.g. tumor, fracture)
• metabolic diseases RA, osteoporosis, prolonged history of steroid use, symptoms of vertebrobasilary insufficiency, pregnancy, cervical spinal stenosis, bilateral upper extremity symptoms etc.)
• history of whiplash injury within the past six weeks
• evidence of central nervous system involvement, to include hyperreflexia, sensory disturbances in the hand, intrinsic muscle wasting of the hands, unsteadiness during walking, nystagmus, loss of visual acuity, impaired sensation of the face, altered taste, the presence of pathological reflexes (i.e. positive Hoffman's and/or Babinski reflexes
• two or more positive neurologic signs consistent with nerve root compression, including any two of the following: muscle weakness involving a major muscle group of the upper extremity, diminished upper extremity muscle stretch reflex (biceps brachii, brachioradialis, or triceps reflex), diminished or absent sensation to pinprick in any upper extremity dermatome
• prior surgery to the neck or thoracic spine
• chiropractic or physical therapy treatment for their headaches over the past 6-months
• bilateral headache description
• migraine headaches with or without aura
• workers compensation or pending legal action regarding their headaches
• inability to comply with treatment and follow-up schedule
• we will not recruit individuals whom the researcher is in a position to punish or reward, whether through grades, evaluations, or promotions

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Crossover Assignment

Masking: None (Open label)

---

48 participants in 2 patient groups

Treatment (thoracic manipulation)

Experimental group

Description:

Patients in the initial manipulation group will attend physical therapy two sessions per week for 3 weeks for a total of 6 sessions. Each treatment session will last for a total of 15 minutes. After the initial manipulation group receives 3 weeks of treatment they will wait for 1-week, be retested, and then crossover into the other group.

Treatment:

Procedure: Thoracic manipulation (Manipulation Group)

Wait-list (thoracic manipulation)

Active Comparator group

Description:

When individuals are assigned to the wait-list control group they will serve as the control for 3 weeks while the initial manipulation group receives treatment. After serving as the wait-list control condition for 3 weeks, this group will then return for testing and will receive the manipulation package as described below at 4 weeks.

Treatment:

Procedure: Thoracic Manipulation (Control wait-list)