Threat Interpretation Bias as Cognitive Marker and Treatment Target in Pediatric Anxiety

University of Denver

Status: Completed

Conditions: Anxiety Disorders

Treatments: Other: Interpretation Control Condition (ICC); Other: Cognitive Bias Modification for Interpretations (CBM-I)

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other; NIH

Identifiers

NCT04245501

1R61MH121552 (U.S. NIH Grant/Contract)

1R61MH121552-01

Details and patient eligibility

About

Anxiety is the most common mental health problem in children and adolescents. This two-phased study will test the effects of an experimental computerized intervention aimed at reducing threat-based thinking (i.e., interpretation bias) in anxious youth. Participants in both the R61 (N=46) and R33 (N=72) trials will be youth ages 10 to 17 with a primary anxiety disorder (Separation, Social, Generalized). In the R61 trial, youth will be randomly assigned to receive 16 sessions over 4 weeks of either a personalized cognitive bias modification program for interpretation bias (CBM-I) or a computerized control condition (ICC). If CBM-I reduces interpretation bias significantly more than the ICC, the R33 trial will commence. In the R33, youth will be randomly assigned to either CBM-I or an equal amount of time in a cognitive restructuring intervention, which also aims to reduce threat-based thinking in anxiety. Please note that only the R61 phase of the trial has been completed and currently this record summary only reflects the R61 phase.

Full description

Anxiety is the most common mental health problem in youth, affecting one in four children and adolescents. Unfortunately, evidence-based treatments (pharmacotherapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy) are costly, not widely available, and ineffective for a substantial proportion of youth. In response, experts have called for novel treatments that directly target mechanisms underlying youth anxiety while simultaneously addressing barriers to care (i.e., cost, accessibility). One such promising mechanism is interpretation bias - the inaccurate interpretation of threat from ambiguity. The investigators have previously demonstrated that interpretation bias occurs in over 90% of anxious youth, is predictive of anxiety severity in clinical samples of youth, and differentiates between anxious and non-anxious youth. These data indicate that interpretation bias may be a ubiquitous phenomenon underlying anxiety expression in children and adolescents and therefore may be an ideal intervention target. Cognitive bias modification for interpretation bias (CBM-I) is a computerized intervention that attempts to reduce anxiety by directly modifying interpretation bias. CBM-I has demonstrated preliminary efficacy for reducing anxiety symptoms in adults. Yet extant CBM-I data in anxious youth are sparse, with little work addressing whether CBM-I significantly reduces interpretation bias, and whether this in turn reduces anxiety symptoms, as well as the dose necessary to reduce both bias and anxiety. This two-phased study tests personalized CBM-I in youth ages 10 to 17 who meet diagnostic criteria for a primary anxiety disorder (Separation, Social, Generalized). In the R61 Phase (N=46), a randomized clinical trial (RCT) examines whether CBM-I personalized to youth anxiety symptoms significantly reduces interpretation bias compared to a computerized interpretation control condition (ICC). The interpretation target will be measured at multiple time points (4, 8, 12, 16 sessions) to identify the optimal dose for reduction in interpretation bias. If the R61 trial results indicate that CBM-I outperforms ICC on interpretation bias reduction, the R33 phase will commence. In the R33 Phase, an RCT (N=72) will validate whether CBM-I significantly reduces interpretation bias, and conducts a mechanism test (i.e., does bias reduction precede and predict anxiety reduction?), by comparing CBM-I to cognitive restructuring, a clinically relevant psychosocial intervention that also targets anxious cognition. Please note that only the R61 phase of the trial has been completed and currently this record summary only reflects the R61 phase. If the R33 phase is funded, it will be registered as a separate NCT.

Enrollment: 50 patients

Sex: All

Ages: 10 to 17 years old

Volunteers: No Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• youth aged 10 to 17
• diagnosed at study baseline with a primary "big three" anxiety disorder (Separation, Social, Generalized)
• standard score greater than or equal to 85 on the Wide Range Achievement Test - Word Reading Subtest (to ensure ability to read stimuli during interpretation bias assessment and CBM-I/ICC), and estimated IQ standard score of at least 80 on the Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence
• youth and consenting parent/legal guardian speak sufficient English to complete consent/assent and study procedures
• no concurrent psychosocial services during study participation to reduce likelihood that other interventions are responsible for change in primary or secondary outcomes
• no psychotropic medications with no plans to start medications during study, or six weeks stable on SSRI or psychostimulant medication and dose with no plans to change medication/dose during study

Exclusion criteria

• severe anxiety indicting that youth requires higher level of care (e.g., intensive treatment such as psychiatric hospitalization), significant diagnostic comorbidity (e.g., presence of psychosis or significant mood disorder), or another primary diagnosis that warrants alternate intervention
• significant uncorrected vision impairment (e.g., uncorrected blindness) that precludes participation in CBM-I/ICC
• safety concerns due to recent or acute suicidality with plan, intent, and/or attempt that warrants alternate intervention

Trial design

Primary purpose: Treatment

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Double Blind

---

50 participants in 2 patient groups, including a placebo group

Cognitive Bias Modification for Interpretations (CBM-I)

Experimental group

Description:

Computerized 16-session intervention aimed at reducing interpretation bias. In this study, CBM-I is personalized to youth anxiety symptoms. During CBM-I sessions, youth indicate whether word-sentence pairs are related, and are provided with feedback aimed to reduce bias.

Treatment:

Other: Cognitive Bias Modification for Interpretations (CBM-I)

Interpretation Control Condition (ICC)

Placebo Comparator group

Description:

Computerized 16-session intervention that is not believed to significantly modify bias. In this study, youth see stimuli personalized to their anxiety symptoms. During ICC sessions, youth see word-sentence pairs and are required to indicate whether word and sentence are related, but are not provided with feedback that aims to "train" a reduction in interpretation bias.

Treatment:

Other: Interpretation Control Condition (ICC)