VR in Undergraduate Anesthesia Training

London Health Sciences Centre Research Institute OR Lawson Research Institute of St. Joseph's

Status: Not yet enrolling

Conditions: Anesthesia

Treatments: Other: Virtual Reality Training

Study type: Interventional

Funder types: Other

Identifiers

NCT07079059

VR in Anesthesia UGME

Details and patient eligibility

About

Medical students learning anesthesia often face challenges in gaining hands-on experience due to the complexity of the operating room environment. Traditional teaching methods, such as lectures and in-person training, can be inconsistent due to variations in clinical exposure and instructor availability. Virtual reality (VR) technology offers an innovative solution by allowing students to practice anesthesia-related skills in a risk-free, immersive environment. This study will evaluate whether VR simulation training can better prepare third-year medical students for their anesthesia rotation compared to traditional methods. Students will be randomly assigned to one of two groups: one will receive VR training before their rotation, while the other will follow the standard curriculum without VR. To assess the effectiveness of VR training, all students will complete pre- and post-rotation surveys measuring their confidence in anesthesia principles, procedural skills, and overall preparedness. Additionally, faculty will use a standardized checklist to evaluate students' performance on key anesthesia procedures during their clinical rotations. By comparing students who received VR training to those who did not, this study will determine if VR can improve knowledge retention, skill development, and confidence in real clinical settings. If successful, VR technology could enhance anesthesia education and provide new training opportunities for medical students, including those in remote or resource-limited settings.

Full description

Anesthesia rotations are complex and challenging, often intimidating for students due to their safety-critical environment. Traditional anesthesia teaching methods for medical students in Canada comes with several challenges such as variability in exposure for students, patient safety concerns with staff, and instructor availability. High-fidelity VR simulations provide an innovative, consistent, and engaging educational experience, allowing students to practice critical skills in a risk-free setting. The purpose of this study is to determine whether VR simulation training improves third-year medical students' perceptions on their clinical performance, confidence, and knowledge retention during anesthesia rotations compared to our current teaching methods. We hypothesize that VR training will result in superior outcomes in student performance and confidence during their Anesthesia rotation. The study will include 180 third-year medical students, randomly assigned to control and experimental groups.

This study involves third-year medical students as participants and will assess the impact of virtual reality (VR) simulation training on their confidence and preparedness for anesthesia rotations. After consent is obtained, participants will be randomly assigned to one of two groups:

1. Experimental Group (VR Training Group) Students will complete a one-hour VR training session on the first day of their anesthesia rotation. Prior to VR training, students in the VR training group will be asked to complete a short survey that will assess the participant's knowledge, confidence, and procedural skills as applicable to their upcoming Anesthesia rotation. This survey will take approximately 5-10 minutes to complete. Virtual reality-based training will use a high-fidelity VR simulation platform on Quest VR headsets, allowing students to practice key anesthesia skills, including airway management techniques (e.g., supraglottic airway placement, endotracheal intubation), anesthetic agent preparation and administration, and patient monitoring during anesthesia.

   A faculty member or research assistant will be available during the session to guide students and answer questions. After completing the VR training, students will proceed with their standard two-week anesthesia rotation in clinical settings. All other aspects of the student's training will remain the same and not be impacted by participation in this study.

   Following completion of the Anesthesia training rotation, participants will be asked to complete a post-rotation online survey. The post-rotation survey will assess knowledge, confidence, and procedural skills through self-rated confidence in anesthesia principles, pharmacology, monitoring, procedural skills (e.g., intubation, airway management and overall preparedness for the operating room. This survey will take approximately 5-10 minutes to complete.

   The VR device will be cleaned using disinfectant wipes between uses.

2. Control Group (Standard Training Group) Students in this group will not receive VR training and will follow the existing standard teaching curriculum without any modification, which includes traditional didactic lectures and hands-on learning in the clinical setting under faculty supervision. All aspects of the student's training will remain the same and not be impacted by participation in this study. Prior to commencing their anesthesia rotation, students will be asked to complete a short survey on that will assess their knowledge, confidence, and procedural skills as applicable to their upcoming Anesthesia rotation. This survey will take approximately 5-10 minutes to complete.

Participants will be asked to complete a post-rotation online survey. The post-rotation survey will assess knowledge, confidence, and procedural skills through self-rated confidence in anesthesia principles, pharmacology, monitoring, procedural skills (e.g., intubation, airway management and overall preparedness for the operating room. This survey will take approximately 5-10 minutes to complete.

Both groups will receive the same pre and post-rotation surveys to complete. The post-rotation survey will assess knowledge, confidence, and procedural skills through self-rated confidence in anesthesia principles, pharmacology, monitoring, procedural skills (e.g., intubation, airway management and overall preparedness for the operating room. The only difference will be that the VR simulation training group participants will indicate "yes" when asked if they underwent VR training which will trigger additional questions regarding their use of VR.

Both groups will also have data related to standard faculty assessments of their rotation performance collected to determine whether VR training had any impact on the participant's performance during their Anesthesia rotation. in addition, faculty will complete questions related to research-specific assessments of students that rate perceived confidence, procedural skills, and overall preparedness of students and will indicate whether they were aware of the student's training modality (VR or traditional) to account for potential bias. Open-ended questions will explore faculty perceptions of differences, improvements, or challenges related to VR-trained students. Ideally, faculty will be blinded to the training method to minimize bias. However, given the practical aspects of clinical teaching, blinding may not always be possible. Faculty will be asked whether they were aware of the student's VR training status. Faculty surveys will be administered after the rotation is complete to allow for a comprehensive assessment of student performance.

Enrollment: 180 estimated patients

Sex: All

Ages: 18+ years old

Volunteers: Accepts Healthy Volunteers

Inclusion criteria

• Enrolled as a third-year medical student in the Undergraduate Medical Education (UME) program at Western University (Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry).

• Scheduled to complete a two-week anesthesia rotation at one of the affiliated teaching hospitals:

  • London: Victoria Hospital, St. Joseph's Hospital, or University Hospital
  • Windsor: Metropolitan Campus or Ouellette Campus

• Willing to participate in the study and provide informed consent.

• Able to complete pre- and post-rotation assessments (self-assessment surveys and procedural skills checklist) administered in the English language.

• 18 years of age or older

Exclusion criteria

• Prior clinical anesthesia experience before their core anesthesia rotation, including: Participation in an Optional Clinical Learning Opportunity (OCLO) in anesthesia. Completion of a summer elective or placement in anesthesia. Completion of an anesthesia selective before their core anesthesia rotation.
• Previous exposure to the VR training platform used in the study (e.g., prior experience with the specific VR simulation software for anesthesia training).
• Students who do not consent to participate in the study or do not wish to be randomized into either the VR or control group.
• Students unable to complete the study assessments in the English language, including: Pre- and post-rotation surveys. Observer-completed procedural skills checklist (during clinical rotations).
• Medical or personal conditions preventing participation, such as: severe motion sickness or vertigo that would prevent the use of VR headsets. Any condition that significantly impacts vision or motor function, affecting the ability to engage with VR simulations.
• Students who are experience nausea.

Trial design

Primary purpose: Other

Allocation: Randomized

Interventional model: Parallel Assignment

Masking: Single Blind

---

180 participants in 2 patient groups

Virtual Reality Training

Experimental group

Description:

Students will complete a one-hour VR training session on the first day of their anesthesia rotation. Virtual reality-based training will use a high-fidelity VR simulation platform on Quest VR headsets, allowing students to practice key anesthesia skills, including airway management techniques (e.g., supraglottic airway placement, endotracheal intubation), anesthetic agent preparation and administration, and patient monitoring during anesthesia. questions. After completing the VR training, students will proceed with their standard two-week anesthesia rotation in clinical settings.

Treatment:

Other: Virtual Reality Training

Standard Training

No Intervention group

Description:

Students in this group will not receive VR training and will follow the existing standard teaching curriculum without any modification, which includes traditional didactic lectures and hands-on learning in the clinical setting under faculty supervision. All aspects of the student's training will remain the same and not be impacted by participation in this study.